Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 05 Nov 2007
The Duke, The Professors, And the Great Coral Reef Controversy of 1887-1888
The Duke, The Professors, And the Great Coral Reef Controversy of 1887-1888
Page Range: 90 – 98
In September 1887 the Duke of Argyll published an article entitled ‘A great lesson’ denouncing Darwin's coral reef theory and alleging that it continued to be supported in the face of new evidence contradicting it because of the authority of Darwin's name and the status of his disciples in British science. His attack touched off a robust correspondence in The Nineteenth Century which soon spread to Nature, and in which T. H. Huxley was the chief defender both of Darwin's views and of scientific procedures. Partly this controversy revolved around the interpretation of coral reefs themselves, but partly also it sprang from the resentment of scientists at the Duke's charge that they were swayed in their judgements by other than objective scientific criteria and modes of argument. The Duke was, in effect, anticipating later interpretations of science as a social activity, but as a result of the exaggerated and polemical nature of his contributions this insight was lost sight of as the scientists defended both their methods and Darwin's views. On the substantive question of the origin of coral reefs the Duke and his supporters were later shown to be largely wrong and Darwin largely right, and the incident did nothing to advance the understanding of the reefs. Had this discussion not eclipsed the Duke's point about the nature of reasoning and judgement in science, he might have made a more lasting contribution to the understanding of science itself.
AGASSIZ, E., ed., 1885, Louis Agassiz: his life and correspondence: London, Macmillan, 2 volumes, 400 and 394 pp.
ANDERSON, W. S., 1888-1889, The solubility of carbonate of lime in fresh and sea water: Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, v. 16, p. 319-324.
ANON., 1887, ‘The conspiracy of silence’ (by An Old Pupil of Wyville Thomson's): Nature, London, v. 37, p. 200.
ARGYLL, DOWAGER DUCHESS OF, ed., 1906, Duke of Argyll: autobiography and memoirs: London, John Murray, 2 volumes.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1851, On tertiary leaf-beds in the Isle of Mull: Journal of the Geological Society of London, v. 7, p. 89-103.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1864, On law in organic life: Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, v. 5, p. 265-293.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1867, The reign of law: London, Alexander Strahan, 435 pp.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1868, On the physical geography of Argyllshire in connection with its geological structure: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London, v. 24, p. 255-273.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1874, The anniversary address of the President: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London, v. 30, p. xxxiv-lxix.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1883, Continuity and catastrophes in geology. An address to the Edinburgh Geological Society on its fiftieth anniversary, November 1, 1883: Edinburgh, David Douglas, 32 pp.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1887a, Professor Huxley on Canon Liddon: The Nineteenth Century, v. 21, p. 321-339.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1887b, Science falsely so called: The Nineteenth Century, v. 21, p. 771-774.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1887c, A great lesson: The Nineteenth Century, v. 22, p. 293-309.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1887d, ‘A conspiracy of silence’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 53-54.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1888a, ‘A conspiracy of silence’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 246.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1888b, ‘A conspiracy of silence’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 293.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1888c, A great confession: The Nineteenth Century, v. 23, p. 142-160.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1891a, Professor Huxley on the warpath: The Nineteenth Century, v. 29, p. 1-33.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1891b, Professor Huxley and the Duke of Argyll: The Nineteenth Century, v. 29, p. 685-689.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1894a, The glacial theory: The Nineteenth Century, v. 35, p. 337-342.
ARGYLL, DUKE OF, 1894b, Lord Bacon versus Professor Huxley: The Nineteenth Century, v. 36, p. 959-969.
BARLOW, N., ed., 1958, The autobiography of Charles Darwin 1809-1882: London, Collins, 253 pp.
BASSETT-SMITH, P. W., 1889, Coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 222.
BONNEY, T. G., 1887a, ‘A conspiracy of silence’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 25-26.
BONNEY, T. G., 1887b, ‘The conspiracy of silence’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 77.
BONNEY, T. G., 1889a, The structure and distribution of coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 77.
BONNEY, T. G., 1889b, The structure and distribution of coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 125.
BONNEY, T. G., 1889c, Coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 222.
BOURNE, G. C, 1888a, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 414-415.
BOURNE, G. C., 1888b, The atoll of Diego Garcia and the coral formations of the Indian Ocean: Proceedings of the Royal Society of London, v. 43, p. 440-461.
BOURNE, G. C., 1888c, The atoll of Diego Garcia and the coral formations of the Indian Ocean: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 546-550.
BOURNE, G. C., 1888d, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 38, p. 5.
BOURNE, G. C., 1888e, The coral reefs of the Peninsula of Sinai: Nature, London, v. 39, p. 172.
CLARKE, S. F., 1887, ‘The conspiracy of silence’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 200.
DANA, J. D., 1885, Origin of coral reefs and islands: American Journal of Science, ser. 3, v. 30, p. 89-105, 169-191.
DARWIN, C. R., 1838, On certain areas of elevation and subsidence in the Pacific and Indian Oceans, as deduced from the study of coral formations: Proceedings of the Geological Society of London, v. 2, p. 552-554.
DARWIN, C. R., 1839, Journal of researches into the geology and natural history of the various countries visited by H.M.S. Beagle, under the command of Capt. FitzRoy, R.N., from 1832 to 1836: London, T. & W. Boone, 629 pp.
DARWIN, C. R., 1842, The structure and distribution of coral reefs: London, Smith, Elder, 214 pp.
DARWIN, F., ed., 1887, Life and letters of Charles Darwin, including an autobiographical chapter: London, John Murray, 3 volumes.
DAVIS, W. M., 1928, The coral reef problem: New York, American Geographical Society, Special Publication 9.
DRYER, C. R., 1888. Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 38, p. 6.
GARDNER, J. STARKIE, 1889, Origin of coral islands: Nature, London, v. 39, p. 435.
GEIKIE, A., 1865, The scenery of Scotland viewed in connexion with its physical geology: London, Macmillan, 360 pp.
GEIKIE, A., 1883a, The origin of coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 29, p. 107-110.
GEIKIE, A., 1883b, The origin of coral reefs II: Nature, London, v. 29, p. 124-128.
GEIKIE, A., 1900, The Duke of Argyll: Nature, London, v. 62, p. 13-14.
GEIKIE, A., 1901, Campbell, George John Douglas, Duke of Argyll: Dictionary of National Biography, London, Supplement 1, p. 385-391.
GEIKIE, A., 1904, Scottish reminiscences: Glasgow, James Maclehose, 447 pp.
GEIKIE, A., 1924, A long life's work: an autobiography: London, Macmillan, 426 p.
GUPPY, H. B., 1886, Notes on the characters and mode of formation of the coral reefs of the Solomon Islands, being the results of observations made in 1882-1884 during the surveying cruise of H.M.S. Lark: Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, v. 13, p. 857-904.
GUPPY, H. B., 1887a, Observations on the recent calcareous formations of the Solomon group: Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, v. 32, p. 545-581.
GUPPY, H. B., 1887b, The Solomon Islands: their geology, general features, and suitability for colonization: London, Swan Sonnenschein, Lowrey, 152 pp.
GUPPY, H. B., 1888a, A criticism of the theory of subsidence as affecting coral reefs: Scottish Geographical Magazine, v. 4, p. 121-137.
GUPPY, H. B., 1888b, An explanation: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 342-343.
GUPPY, H. B., 1888c, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 462.
GUPPY, H. B., 1888d, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 604.
GUPPY, H. B., 1889a, The structure and distribution of coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 53-54.
GUPPY, H. B., 1889b, The structure and distribution of coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 102.
GUPPY, H. B., 1889c, The structure and distribution of coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 173-174.
GUPPY, H. B., 1889d, Coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 222.
HUXLEY, L., ed., 1918, Life and letters of Sir Joseph Dalton Hooker, O.M., G.C.S.I.: London, John Murray, 2 volumes.
HUXLEY, T. H., 1886, Science and morals: The Fortnightly Review, n.s., v. 40, p. 788-802.
HUXLEY, T. H., 1887a, Scientific and pseudo-scientific realism: The Nineteenth Century, v. 21, p. 191-205.
HUXLEY, T. H., 1887b, Science and pseudo-science: The Nineteenth Century, v. 21, p. 481-498.
HUXLEY, T. H., 1887c, Science and the bishops: The Nineteenth Century, v. 22, p. 625-641.
HUXLEY, T. H., 1888, The Duke of Argyll's charges against men of science: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 342.
HUXLEY, T. H., 1890, The lights of the Church and the light of Science: The Nineteenth Century, v. 28, p. 5-22.
HUXLEY, T. H., 1891, Illustrations of Mr. Gladstone's controversial method: The Nineteenth Century, v. 29, p. 455-467.
IRVINE, R., 1888a, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 461-462.
IRVINE, R., 1888b, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 509.
IRVINE, R., 1888c, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 605.
IRVINE, R., 1888d, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 38, p. 54.
JUDD, J. W., 1888a, ‘A conspiracy of silence’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 272.
JUDD, J. W., 1888b, The Duke of Argyll's charges against men of science: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 317-318.
JUDD, J. W., 1909, Darwin and geology, in A. C. Seward, ed., Darwin and modern science, Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, p. 337-384.
KUHN, T. S., 1962, The structure of scientific revolutions: Chicago, University of Chicago Press, 172 pp.
LILLY, W. S., 1886, Materialism and morality: The Fortnightly Review, n.s., v. 40, p. 575-594.
MASON, J. W., 1978, The Duke of Argyll and the land question in late nineteenth-century Britain: Victorian Studies, v. 21, p. 149-170.
MOORE, W. U., 1889a, Coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 203-204.
MOORE, W. U., 1889b, Coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 48, p. 271-272.
MURRAY, J., 1880, On the structure and origin of coral reefs and islands: Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, v. 10, p. 505-518.
MURRAY, J., 1888a, ‘Coral formations’: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 414.
MURRAY, J., 1888b, Coral formation: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 438.
MURRAY, J., 1888c, Structure, origin and distribution of coral reefs and islands: Proceedings of the Royal Institution, v. 12, p. 251-262.
MURRAY, J., 1889a, Structure, origin, and distribution of coral reefs and islands: Nature, London, v. 39, p. 424-428.
MURRAY, J., 1889b, Coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 222.
MURRAY, J., 1889c, Coral reefs: Nature, London, v. 40, p. 294.
MURRAY, J. and IRVINE, R., 1889, On coral reefs and other carbonate of lime formations in modern seas: Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, v. 17, p. 79-109.
MEADE, T. MELLARD, 1887, The theories of the origin of coral reefs and islands: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 54.
MEADE, T. MELLARD, 1888a, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 488.
MEADE, T. MELLARD, 1888b, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 535.
ROSS, J. G., 1888a, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 462.
ROSS, J. G., 1888b, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 584-585.
RUPKE, N. A., 1976, Bathybius haeckelii and the psychology of scientific discovery: theory instead of observed data controlled the late 19th century ‘discovery’ of a primitive form of life: Studies in the History and Philosophy of Science, v. 7, p. 53-62.
RUSSELL, G. W. E., 1916, The Duke of Argyll: in Portraits of the seventies: London, T. Fisher Unwin, p. 63-74.
SMITH, J., 1838, On indications of changes in the relative level of sea and land in the west of Scotland: Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal, v. 25, p. 378-395.
STEERS, J. A. and STODDART, D. R., 1977, The origin of fringing reefs, barrier reefs, and atolls: in O. A. Jones and R. Endean, eds., Biology and geology of coral reefs, London, Academic Press, volume 4, p. 21-57.
STODDART, D. R., ed., 1962, ‘Coral islands,’ by Charles Darwin, with an introduction, map, and remarks: Atoll Research Bulletin, v. 88, p. 1-20.
STODDART, D. R., 1988, Joseph Beete Jukes, the ‘Cambridge connection,’ and the theory of reef development in Australia in the nineteenth century: Earth Sciences History, this issue.
WALTHER, J., 1888, Die Korallenriffe der Sinaihalbinsel: Abhandlungen aus dem Königlich Sachsische Gesellschaft der Wissenschaften, Mathematisch-Physische Classe, v. 14, p. 437-506.
WHARTON, W. J. L., 1888, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 393-395.
WILSON-BARKER, D., 1888, Coral formations: Nature, London, v. 37, p. 605.