Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 05 Nov 2007
Specialities, Problems, and Localism the Reception of Continental Drift in Australia 1920-1940
Specialities, Problems, and Localism the Reception of Continental Drift in Australia 1920-1940
and
Page Range: 84 – 95
Although A.L. Wegener signalled that the Australasian region was an important testing-ground for his theory of continental drift, his views aroused little interest among Australian scientists in the period 1920-1940. I argue that specialization and geological "localism" were important factors in this response. Most scientists were silent or perhaps passively resistant, I suggest, because they saw no particular value in the theory for the problems which occupied them. Those few who did publicly support or oppose the theory often did so with respect to specialist concerns or specific problems. This response has implications not only for the general story of the "modern revolution" in the earth sciences but also for philosophical and social models of their acceptance.
ANDREWS, Ernest Clayton, 1926, Hypothesis of Mountain-Building: Bulletin of the Geological Society of America, 37, 439-454.
ANDREWS, Ernest Clayton, 1938, Presidential Address: Some Major Problems in Structural Geology: The Proceedings of the Linnean Society of New South Wales, 63, iv-xl.
CAREY, S.W., 1976, The Expanding Earth: Developments in Geotectonics 10, New York, Elsevier.
COTTON, Leo Arthur, 1923, Some Fundamental Problems of Diastrophism and their Geological Corollaries with Special Reference to Polar Wandering: American Journal of Science, 5th series, 6, 453-503.
COTTON, Leo Arthur, 1929, Presidential Address: Causes of Diastrophism and their Status in Current Geological Thought: Report of the Nineteenth Meeting of ANZAAS (Hobart, 1928) 19, 171-210.
DAVID, Tannant William Edgeworth, 1928, Notes on Lecture by David entitled - Drifting Continents: The Wegener Hypothesis: The Australian Geographer, 1, Part 1, 60-62.
DAVID, T.W.E. and William Rowan BROWNE, 1950, The Geology of the Commonwealth of Australia. 1: London, Edward Arnold & Co.
DU TOIT, Alexander Logie, 1921, Land Connections Between the Other Continents and South Africa in the Past: South African Journal of Science, 18, 120-140.
DU TOIT, A.L., 1927, A Geological Comparison of South America with South Africa: Washington, Carnegie Institution.
DU TOIT, A.L., 1929, Some Reflections upon a Geological Comparison of South Africa with South America: Proceedings of the Geological Society of South Africa, 31, xix-xxxviii.
DU TOIT, A.L., 1937, Our Wandering Continents: Edinburgh, Oliver & Boyd.
DUNN, E.R., 1923, The Geographical Distribution of Amphibians: The American Naturalist, 57, 129-135.
DUNN, E.R., 1925, The Host-Parasite Method and the Distribution of Frogs: The American Naturalist, 59, 370-375.
EVANS, John William, 1923, The Wegener Hypothesis of Continental Drift: Nature, 111, 393-394.
FRANKEL, Henry, 1976, Alfred Wegener and the Specialists: Centaurus, 20, 305-323.
FRANKEL, Henry, 1981, The Paleobiogeographical Debate over the Problem of Disjunctively Distributed Life Forms: Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 12, no. 3, 211-259.
FRANKEL, Henry, 1984, Biogeography, Before and After the Rise of Sea Floor Spreading: Studies in History and Philosophy of Science, 15, 141-168.
HARRISON, Launcelot, 1924, The Migration Route of the Australian Marsupial Fauna: The Australian Zoologist, 3, 247-263.
HARRISON, Launcelot, 1926a, Crucial Evidence for Antarctic Radiation: American Naturalist, 60, 374-83.
HARRISON, Launcelot, 1926b, The Wegener Hypothesis from a Biological Standpoint: Sydney University Science Journal, 10, 10-19.
HARRISON, Launcelot, 1928, The Composition and Origins of the Australian Fauna, with Special Reference to the Wegener Hypothesis: Report of the Eighteenth Meeting of ANZAAS (Perth, 1926), 18, 332-396.
JOLY, John, 1925, The Surface-History of the Earth: Oxford, Clarendon Press.
LAKE, Philip, 1933, Gutenberg's Fleisstheorie: A Theory of Continental Spreading: Geological Magazine, 70, 116-121.
LAUDAN, Larry, 1977, Progress and its Problems: Berkeley,: University of California Press.
LAUDAN, Rachel, 1982, Tensions in the Concept of Geology: Natural History or Natural Philosophy: Earth Sciences History, 1, 7-13.
LE GRAND, H.E., 1986, Steady as a Rock: Methodology and Moving Continents: In J. Schuster and R. Yeo, eds., The Politics and Rhetoric of Scientific Method, Dordrecht: Reidel (forthcoming).
LONGMAN, H.A., 1924, The Zoogeography of Marsupials: Memoirs of the Queensland Museum, 8, 1-15.
MATTHEW, William Diller, 1915, Climate and Evolution: Annals of the New York Academy of Science, 24, 171-318.
METCALF, Maynard M., 1920, Upon an Important Method of Studying Problems of Relationship and of Geographical Distribution: Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 6, 432-433.
METCALF, Maynard, M., 1923, The Origin and Distribution of the Anura: The American Naturalist, 57, 385-411.
MOLENGRAAFF, Gustaaf Adolf Frederick, 1916, The Coral Reef Problem and Isostasy: Nederlandse Akademie van Wetenschappen, 19, 610-627.
NICHOLLS, George E., 1933, Presidential Address (Section D. Zoology): the Composition and Biogeographical Relations of the Fauna of Western Australia: Report of the Twenty-first Meeting of ANZAAS (Sydney, 1932), 21, 93-138.
NOBLE, G.K., 1922, The Phylogeny of the Salientia: Bulletin of the American Museum of Natural History, 46, 1-87.
NOBLE, G.K., 1925, The Evolution and Dispersal of the Frogs: The American Naturalist, 59, 265-271.
OLIPHANT, Mark, 1981, Formal Opening: in S.W. Carey, ed., The Expanding Earth: A Symposium, Hobart, University of Tasmania, vii-viii.
SMIT SIBINGA, G.L., 1927, Wegener's Theorie en het Ontstaan van den Oostelijken O.I. Archipel: Tijdschrift van het Koninklijk Nederlandsch Aardijkskundig Genootschap, 44 (ser. 2), 581-598.
SOERGEL, Wolfgang, 1916, Die atlantische ‘Spalte’. Kritische Bemerkungen zu A. Wegeners Theorie von der Kontinental-verschiebung: Zeitschrift der Deutschen Geologischen Gesellschaft, 68, 200-239.
UNIVERSITY OF MELBOURNE, University of Melbourne Annual Examination Papers.
WADE, Arthur, 1927, The Search for Oil in New Guinea: Bulletin of the American Association of Petroleum Geologists, 11, 157-176.
WADE, Arthur, 1934, The Distribution of Oil-fields from the View-Point of the Theory of Continental Spreading: Proceedings of the World Petroleum Congress (London, 1933), 1, 73-77.
WADE, Arthur, 1935, New Theory of Continental Spreading: Bulletin of the Americal Association of Petroleum Geologists, 19, 1806-1818.
WADE, Arthur, 1941, The Geology of the Antarctic Continent and its Relationship to Neighbouring Land Areas: Proceedings of the Royal Society of Queensland, 52, 1, 24-35.
WADE, L. Keith, The Plan of the Earth and its Origin: Proceedings of the Royal Geographical Society of Australasia, South Australian Branch, 1926-1927, 1-29.
WEGENER, A.L., 1912, Die Entstehung der Kontinente: Geologische Rundschau, 3, 276-292.
WEGENER, A.L., 1915, Die Entstehung der Kontinente und Ozeane: Brunswick, Friedrich Vieweg & Sohn.
WEGENER, A.L., 1922, The Origin of Continents and Oceans: Discovery, 3, No. 29 (May), 114-118.
WEGENER, A.L., 1924, The Origin of Continents and Oceans: trans. J.G.A. Skerl of 3rd German ed., London, Methuen & Co. Ltd.
WEGENER, A.L., 1929, The Origin of Continents and Oceans: trans. John Biram of 4th German ed., rept. New York, 1966, Dover.
WHITLEY, Richard, 1976, Umbrella and Polytheistic Scientific Disciplines and Their Elites: Social Studies of Science, 6, 471-97.
WING EASTON, Nicolaas, 1921a, On Some Extensions of Wegener's Hypothesis and their Bearing upon the Meaning of the Term - Geosynclines and Isostasy: Verhandelingen Geologisch Mijnbouwkundig Genootschap voor Nederland an Kolonien, 5 (Geol. ser.), 113-133.
WING EASTON, Nicolaas, 1921b, Het ontstaan van den maleischen Archipel, bezien in het licht van Wegener's hypothesen: Tidjschrift van het Koninklijk, Nederlandsch Aardriljkskundig Genootschap, 38, 484-512.
WRIGHT, W.B. et al, 1923, The Wegener Hypothesis: Discussion at the British Association, Hull, Nature, 111, 30-31.