Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | 
Online Publication Date: 09 May 2014

The Iron Creek Meteorite: The Curious History of the Manitou Stone and the Claim for its Repatriation

Page Range: 150 – 175
DOI: 10.17704/eshi.33.1.2457k54466405851
Save
Download PDF

Canada's Iron Creek meteorite, a 320 lb (145 kg) Group IIIAB medium octahedrite iron, was long venerated by the First Nations in Alberta as their sacred Manitou Stone, but it was taken without authority from them by Methodist missionaries in 1866. That began the meteorite's long odyssey, as it was transferred first to the Methodist Mission in Victoria (now Pakan) Alberta; then to the Red River Mission in Winnipeg, Manitoba; then to the Wesleyan Methodist Church's Mission Rooms in Toronto, Ontario; then to Victoria College in Cobourg, Ontario; then to the campus of the University of Toronto in Toronto, Ontario; then to the Royal Ontario Museum in Toronto; and finally to the Provincial Museum of Alberta (now the Royal Alberta Museum) in Edmonton. In recent years, a First Nations movement to repatriate the meteorite to a place near its original find site has been initiated. As of now, the meteorite remains on display at the Royal Alberta Museum's Syncrude Gallery of Aboriginal Culture, where it is a prized showpiece. The present paper explores the curious history and cultural significance of this fabled meteorite, its long odyssey, the issues surrounding the claims for its repatriation, the Royal Alberta Museum's present policy, and a possible way forward.


Alberta Hansard. 1972. 1 June. Copy in Bursar's Office Fonds, Fonds 2001. Series 19. Records Relating to the Iron Creek Meteorite. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Bell, Catherine. 2009. Restructuring the relationship: domestic repatriation and Canadian law reform. In: Protection of First Nations Cultural Heritage. Laws, Policy, and Reform, edited by Catherine Bell and Robert K. Paterson, 15-77. Vancouver, Toronto: University of British Columbia Press.

Berry, Susan. 2001. Letter to Bruce McGillivray and Albert Finnamore. 3 September. Iron Creek Papers, Royal Alberta Museum, Edmonton, Alberta.

Blundell, Valda and Grant, Laurence. 1989. Preserving our heritage: getting beyond boycotts and demonstrations. Inuit Art Quarterly 4, Winter: 12-16.

Burke, John G. 1986. Cosmic Debris. Meteorites in History. Berkeley, Los Angeles, London: University of California Press.

Burwash, Nathanael. 1927. The History of Victoria College. Toronto: The Victoria College Press.

Butler, William Francis. 1872. The Great Lone Land: A Tale of Travel and Adventure in the North-West of America. Toronto: MacMillan Company of Canada.

Byrne, William. 1999. Letter to Roseanne Runte. 14 October. Iron Creek Papers, Royal Alberta Museum, Edmonton, Alberta.

Canadian Museums Association. 2006. Ethical Guidelines. Ottawa: Canadian Museums Association.

Coleman, Arthur P. 1886. A meteorite from the northwest. Transactions of the Royal Society of Canada 4: 97.

Colpitts, George. 2009. The Methodists' great 1869 camp meeting and Aboriginal conservation strategies in the North Saskatchewan River Valley. Great Plains Quarterly 9: 9-27.

De Luna, Phyllis. 1981. Rendezvous with an angel. The Alberta Teachers' Association Magazine 61: 10-12.

Dempsey, Hugh A. 1984. Big Bear. The End of Freedom. Vancouver, Toronto: Douglas & McIntyre.

Donaghey, Sam. 1979. Letter to Commissioner, Alberta 75th Anniversary Commission. 12 October. Iron Creek Papers, Royal Alberta Museum, Edmonton, Alberta.

Fisher, Darlene. 2012. Repatriation issues in First Nations heritage collections. Journal of Integrated Studies 1, No. 3: 1-10.

Fraser, Lorna D. 1972. Letter to Allen Ronaghan. 19 June. President's Office Fonds, Fonds 2021. Series 2. General Subject File. Meteor 1957-1983. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Gerson, Jen. 2012. First Nations college calls for return of sacred meteorite from Alberta museum. 8 August. The National Post.

Gooch, Paul. 2001a. Letter to Bruce McGillivray. 7 November. Iron Creek Papers, Royal Alberta Museum, Edmonton, Alberta.

Gooch, Paul. 2001b. Draft letter to Board of Regents, Victoria University. 7 November. Iron Creek Papers, Royal Alberta Museum, Edmonton, Alberta.

Goyette, Linda. 2004. The Manitou Stone 1870 to 1891. In: Edmonton in Our Own Words, 86-106. Edmonton: The University of Alberta Press.

Grady, Monica. 2000. Catalogue of Meteorites. With Special Reference to those Represented in the Collection of the Natural History Museum, London. Fifth edition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Guidelines for Applications to Repatriate First Nations Sacred Ceremonial Objects. No date.

Henry, Alexander and Thompson, David. 1965. New Light on the Early History of the Greater Northwest. The Manuscript Journals of Alexander Henry Fur Trader of the Northwest Company and of David Thompson Official Geographer and Explorer of the Same Company 1799-1814, edited by Elliott Coues. Volume 2: The Saskatchewan and Columbia Rivers. Minneapolis: Ross & Haines, Inc.

Hodgetts, John E. 1972. Letter to Horst A. Schmid, 9 May. Bursar's Office Fonds, Fonds 2001. Series 19. Records Relating to the Iron Creek Meteorite. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Iron Creek (Victoria). No date. Unsigned document partially reprinted in Whyte, Anthony, Meteorites of Alberta. 2009. Edmonton: The University of Alberta Press: 15.

Ives, Jack. 2001. Letter to Bill Byrne. 23 March. Iron Creek Papers, Royal Alberta Museum, Edmonton, Alberta.

List of Guests Specially Invited to Opening Alberta Meteorite Exhibit. 1973. 10 June. Copy in Earth and Atmospheric Sciences Department, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta.

Lowey, Mark. 1993. Manitou's meteorite. 6 March. Calgary Herald.

Markowitz, Sam. 2012. A meteorite and a lost city: mutually beneficial solutions through alternative dispute resolution. Cardoza Journal of Conflict Resolution 14: 219-250.

McCord, Thomas. 2001. Vic's meteorite donated to Alberta museum. 28 November. Strand 44, No. 7: 1.

McCracken, Ryan. 2012. Blue Quills president makes waves with Manitou Stone request. Spiritually important meteorite remains at Royal Alberta Museum. 25 September. St. Paul Journal. Accessed http://www.spjournal.com/article/20120925/STP0801/309259955/-1/STP08/blue-quills-president-makes-waves

McDougall, John. 1888. George Millward McDougall. The Pioneer, Patriot and Missionary. Toronto: William Briggs.

McDougall, John. 1898. Pathfinding on Plain and Prairie: Stirring Scenes of Life in the Canadian North-West. Toronto: William Briggs.

McDougall, John. 1911. In the Days of the Red River Rebellion. Life and Adventure in the Far West of Canada (1868-1872). Toronto: William Briggs.

McGillivray, Bruce. 2002a. Letter to Paul Gooch. 3 January. Bursar's Office Fonds, Fonds 2001. Series 19. Records Relating to the Iron Creek Meteorite. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

McGillivray, Bruce. 2002b. Letter to Mark Rasmussen, 4 January. Quoted in Steinhauer, Stewart. Stolen sacred object. Freedom of Information Act request brings proof of conspiracy to keep sacred meteorite from its original owners. 3 May. The Straight Goods News: 2. Accessed http://www.straightgoods.ca/ViewFeature5.cfm?REF=458&Cookies=yes

McGillivray, Bruce. 2004. Letter to Howard Plotkin. 10 June. Personal communication.

McNeil, Kent. 1999. Sovereignty and the Aboriginal Nations of Rupert's Land. Manitoba History 37, Spring/Summer: 2-8.

Meen, Victor Ben. 1951. Letter to A. B. Moore. 13 March. Iron Creek file, Department of Mineralogy, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Ontario.

Meen, Victor Ben. 1957a. Letter to A. B. Moore. 31 January. President's Office Fonds, Fonds 2021. Series 2. General Subject File. Meteor 1957-1983. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Meen, Victor Ben. 1957b. Letter to A. B. Moore. 27 February. Iron Creek file, Department of Mineralogy, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Ontario.

Memorandum of Agreement made as of the first day of September, 1972 between the Board of Regents of Victoria University … and The Province of Alberta. 1972. Bursar's Office Fonds, Fonds 2001. Series 19. Records Relating to the Iron Creek Meteorite. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Millman, Peter and McKinley, D. W. R. 1967. Stars fall over Canada. Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada. 61: 277-294.

Milton, Viscount and Cheadle, Walter Butler. 1865. The North-West Passage by Land. Being the Narrative of an Expedition from the Atlantic to the Pacific Undertaken with the View of Exploring a Route Across the Continent to British Columbia Through British Territory, by One of the Northern Passes in the Rocky Mountains. London: Cassell, Petter, and Galpin.

Moore, A. B. 1957. Letter to Victor Ben Meen. 21 February. President's Office Fonds, Fonds 2021. Series 2. General Subject File. Meteor 1957-1983. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Morris, Alexander. 1880. The Treaties of Canada with the Indians of Manitoba and the North-West Territories, Including the Negotiations on Which They Were Based, and Other Information Relating Thereto. Toronto: Belfords, Clarke & Co.

Mussieux, Ron and Beaudoin, Alwynne B. 2004. Iron Creek Meteorite/Manitou Stone Consultations Process and Feedback from the Scientific Community with Additional Evaluation, Comments, and Recommendations. 21 October.

Nix, James Ernest. 1960. Mission Among the Buffalo. The Labours of the Reverends George M. and John C. McDougall in the Canadian Northwest, 1860-1876. Toronto: The Ryerson Press.

Parry, Allison. 2004. Iron Creek Meteorite/Manitou Stone First Nations Consultations Report. June.

Plotkin, Howard. 2004. Letter to Bruce McGillivray. 18 June. Personal communication.

Province of Alberta. 2008. First Nations Sacred Ceremonial Objects Repatriation Act. Edmonton: Alberta Queen's Printer.

Province of Alberta. 2012. Blackfoot First Nations Sacred Ceremonial Objects Repatriation Regulation. Edmonton: Alberta Queen's Printer.

Ronaghan, Allen. 1972. Where was the Iron Creek meteorite? Archaeological Society of Alberta Newsletter. Copy in Earth and Atmospheric Sciences Department, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta.

Ronaghan, Allen. 1973. The Iron Creek meteorite. Alberta Historical Review. 21:10-12.


Rupert's Land. No date. The Canadian Encyclopedia. Accessed http://thecanadianencyclopedia.com/articles/ruperts-land

Schmid, Horst A. 1972. Letter to John E. Hodgetts. 26 April. Iron Creek file, Department of Mineralogy, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Ontario.

Scott, Edward R. D.; Wasson, John T.; and Buchwald, V. F. 1973. The chemical classification of iron meteorites. VII. A reinvestigation of irons with Ge concentrations between 25 and 80 ppm. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta. 37(8): 1957-1983.

Sissons, Charles Bruce. 1952. A History of Victoria University. Toronto: University of Toronto Press.

Southesk, Earl of. 1875. Saskatchewan and the Rocky Mountains. A Diary and Narrative of Travel, Sport, and Adventure, During a Journey Through the Hudson's Bay Company's Territories, in 1859 and 1860. Toronto: James Campbell and Son.

Spalding, David. 1971. Letter to Victor Ben Meen. 22 January. Iron Creek file, Department of Mineralogy, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Ontario.

Spratt, Christopher. 1989. Canada's Iron Creek meteorite. Journal of the Royal Astronomical Society of Canada 83: 81-91.

Steinhauer, Stewart. 2012. Stolen sacred object. Freedom of Information Act request brings proof of conspiracy to keep sacred meteorite from its rightful owners," The Straight Goods News. 3 May. Accessed http://www.straightgoods.ca/ViewFeature5.cfm?REF=458&Cookies=yes

Stephenson, Mrs. Frederick C. 1925. One Hundred Years of Canadian Methodist Missions, 1824-1894. Volume 1. Toronto: The Missionary Society of the Methodist Church.

Stokes, F. C. 1972a. Letter to Horst A. Schmid. 2 June. Bursar's Office Fonds, Fonds 2001. Series 19. Records Relating to the Iron Creek Meteorite. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Stokes, F. C. 1972b. Letter to Horst A. Schmid. 23 November. Bursar's Office Fonds, Fonds 2001. Series 19. Records Relating to the Iron Creek Meteorite. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Task Force on Museums and First Peoples. 1994. Turning the Page: Forging New Partnerships Between Museums and First Peoples. Ottawa.

Taylor, John Leonard. 1985. Treaty Research Report. Treaty Six (1876). Treaties and Historical Research Centre, Indian and Northern Affairs. Accessed http://aadnc-aandc.gc.ca/eng/1100100028706/1100100028708

Transfer Agreement … Made as of the twentieth of December, 2001 Between The Board of Regents of Victoria University … and The Provincial Museum of Alberta. 2001. Bursar's Office Fonds, Fonds 2001. Series 19. Records Relating to the Iron Creek Meteorite. Victoria University Archives, Toronto, Ontario.

Walker, T. L. 1935. Letter to E. W. Wallace. 26 February. Iron Creek File, Department of Mineralogy, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Ontario.

Wallace, E. W. 1935. Letter to T. L. Walker. 27 February. Iron Creek File, Department of Mineralogy, Royal Ontario Museum, Toronto, Ontario.

Waxman, Sharon. 2008. Loot. The Battle Over the Stolen Treasures of the Ancient World. New York: Henry Holt and Company.

Whyte, Anthony. 2009. Meteorites of Alberta. Edmonton: The University of Alberta Press.

Wiebe, Rudy. 2008. Big Bear. Toronto: Penguin Canada.


Woolsey, Thomas. 1989. Heaven is Near the Rocky Mountains. The Journals and Letters of Thomas Woolsey, 1855-1869, edited by Hugh A. Dempsey. Calgary: Glenbow Museum.

Young, George. 1897. Manitoba Memories. Leaves from my Life in the Prairie Provinces, 1868-1884. Toronto: William Briggs.

  • Download PDF