Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 02 Dec 2013
"The sea fryseth not": science and the open polar sea in the nineteenth century
"The sea fryseth not": science and the open polar sea in the nineteenth century
Page Range: 235 – 351
While generally dismissed by historians as a romantic fantasy, the theory of an open polar sea fit into the context of a more unified view of the natural world developed in the early nineteenth century and exemplified by romantic philosophical ideas. Oersted's discovery of electromagnetism encouraged research into the possible connections between electricity, magnetism, heat and light. At the same time, there was renewed interest in geomagnetism inspired by Hansteen's revival of the four-pole theory of the Earth's magnetic field. Incorporating these works into a new theory of climate created a space for an ice-free Arctic by allowing a milder climate in the high latitudes. This attempt to fuse the study of meteorology and geomagnetism reinforced existing beliefs in an open polar sea and placed this sailor's dream into a holistic worldview that joined different natural phenomena in an effort to find one unifying principle behind all of nature.
Admiralty. 1856. Discoveries in the Arctic Sea up to 1856. London: Hydrographic Office of the Admiralty. Anonymous. 1818. Analysis of Mr. Barrow's chronological history of voyages into the Arctic regions. Blackwood's Edinburgh Magazine 4: 187-193.
Anonymous. 1819a. Account of the expedition to Baffin's Bay, under Captain Ross and Lieutenant Parry. Edinburgh Philosophical Journal 1: 150-159.
Anonymous. 1819b. Account of the experiments of Morchini, Ridolfi, Firmas and Gibbs, on the influence of light in the development of magnetism. Edinburgh Philosophical Journal. 1: 239-243.
Anonymous. 1819c. The Northwest Passage, the North Pole, and the Greenland ice. American Journal of Science 1: 101-104.
Anonymous. 1820. Remarks on Professor Hansteen's "Inquiries concerning the magnetism of the earth." Edinburgh Philosophical Journal 3: 124-138.
Anonymous. 1830. Polar regions. In: Edinburgh Encyclopedia, edited by David Brewster 17: 1-21. Edinburgh: William Blackwood.
Anonymous. 1832. Variation of the needle. In: Edinburgh Encyclopedia, edited by David Brewster 18: 144-163. Philadelphia: Joseph Parker.
Anonymous. 1859. Polar regions. In: Encyclopedia Britannica, edited by Thomas Traill 18: 161-181. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black.
B., G. 1819. On the late Arctic voyages. The Monthly Magazine 47: 193-195.
Barrington, Daines. 1818. The possibility of approaching the North Pole. New York: James Eastburn and Co.
Barlow, Peter. 1822. On the anomalous magnetic action of hot iron between the white and blood-red heat. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 112: 117-126.
Barlow, Peter. 1823. Observations and experiments on the daily variation of the horizontal and dipping needles under a reduced directive power. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 113: 326-341.
Barlow, Peter. 1826. Account of the observations and experiments made on the diurnal variation and intensity of the magnetic needle. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 2: 347-365.
Barlow, Peter. 1827. Abstracts and remarks relative to Captain Sabine's experiments of the dip and intensity of the magnetic needle, in different parts of the Northern Hemisphere. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 3: 142-149.
Barrow, John. 1816. Lord Selkirk, and the North-west Passage. Quarterly Review 16: 129-172.
Barrow, John. 1817. On the polar ice and northern passage into the Pacific. Quarterly Review 18: 199-223.
Barrow, John. 1818a. Burney—Behring's Strait and the polar basin. Quarterly Review 18: 431-458.
Barrow, John. 1818b. O'Reilly's voyage to Davis Strait. Quarterly Review 19: 206-214.
Barrow, John. 1819. Ross's voyage of discovery. Quarterly Review 21: 213-262.
Barrow, John. 1821. Parry's voyage of discovery. Quarterly Review 25: 175-216.
Barrow, John. 1823a. Franklin's journey to the polar sea. Quarterly Review 28: 372-409.
Barrow, John. 1823b. North-west Passage—Parry's second voyage. Quarterly Review 30: 231-272.
Beechey, Frederick. 1843. Voyage of Discovery towards the North Pole. London: Richard Bentley.
Brewster, David. 1823. Observations on the mean temperature of the globe. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 9: 201-225. Brewster, David. 1831a. Observations on the mean temperature of the globe. Edinburgh Journal of Science 4: 300-320.
Brewster, David. 1831b. Über die mathematischen Ausdrüke für die mittlere Wärme der Luft und die magnetische Intensität. Annalen der Physik, 2nd Series 21: 323-325.
Caneva, Kenneth. 1997. Physics and Naturphilosophie: a reconnaissance. History of Science 35: 35-106.
Chambers, Neil (ed.). 2000. The Letters of Sir Joseph Banks. London: Imperial College Press.
Chapin, David. 2004. Exploring Other Worlds. Boston: University of Massachusetts Press.
Christie, Samuel Hunter. 1823. On the diurnal deviations of the horizontal needle when under the influence of magnets. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 113: 342-392.
Christie, Samuel Hunter. 1825. On the effects of temperature on the intensity of magnetic forces; and on the diurnal variation of the terrestrial magnetic intensity. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 115: 1-64.
Christie, Samuel Hunter. 1826. On magnetic influence in the solar rays. Philosophical Transactions 116: 219-239.
Christie, Samuel Hunter. 1827. Theory of the diurnal variation of the magnetic needle. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 117: 308-354.
Christie, Samuel Hunter. 1833. Report on the state of our knowledge respecting the magnetism of the Earth. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 3: 105-130.
Cochrane, John. 1824. Letter. New Monthly Magazine and Literary Journal 10: 549-559.
Cumming, James. 1827. On the development of electro-magnetism by heat. Transactions of the Cambridge Philosophical Society 2: 47-76.
Daubuisson, Jean François. 1819. Traité de Géognosie. 2 vols. Paris: Levrault.
Davis, John. 1880. The Voyages and works of John Davis, the Navigator. London: Hakluyt Society.
Fleming, Fergus. 1998. Barrow's Boys. New York: Grove Press.
Forbes, James David. 1832. Report upon the recent progress and present state of meteorology. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 2: 196-225.
Gascoigne, John. 1998. Science in the Service of Empire. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Gibbs, G. 1819. On the connexion between magnetism and light. American Journal of Science 1: 89-90.
Goetzmann, William. 1986. New Lands, New Men. New York: Viking.
Good, Gregory. 1991. Follow the needle: seeking the magnetic poles. Earth Sciences History 10: 154-167.
Hakluyt, Richard. 1972. Voyages and Discoveries. New York: Penguin.
Halley, Edmond. 1702. A New and Correct Sea Chart of the Whole World Shewing the Variations of the Compass as they were Found in the Year MDCC. London: Mount & Page.
Hansteen, Christopher. 1819. Untersuchungen über den Magnetismus der Erde. Christiana: J. Lehmann and C. Gröndahl.
Hansteen, Christopher. 1826. Observations on the position and revolution of the magnetic poles of the earth. Edinburgh Journal of Science 5: 65-71.
Harvey, George. 1834. A Treatise on Meteorology. London: Encyclopedia Metropolitana.
Humboldt, Alexander von. 1817. Des lignes isothermes et de la distribution de la chaleur sur le globe. Annales de chimie 5: 102-112.
Humboldt, Alexander von. 1820. On isothermal lines, and the distribution of heat over the globe. Edinburgh Philosophical Journal 3: 1-20.
Humboldt, Alexander von. 1827. On the principal causes of the difference of temperature on the globe. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 4: 329-346.
Inglefield, Edward. 1852. Report on the return of the Isabel from the Arctic regions. Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 23: 136-145.
Jackson, Charles Ian. (ed.) 2003. The Arctic whaling journals of William Scoresby the younger. 3 vols. London: The Hakluyt Society.
Jackson, Charles Ian. 2007. Three puzzles from early nineteenth century Arctic exploration. The Northern Mariner 17: 1-17.
Jameson, Robert. 1821. Notice of Captain Parry's voyage of discovery. Edinburgh Philosophical Journal 4: 144-155.
King, Richard. 1836. Narrative of a Journey to the Shores of the Arctic Ocean. 2 vols. London: Richard Bentley.
Kirwan, Richard. 1787. An Estimate of the Temperature at Different Latitudes. London: J. Davis.
Kuhn, Thomas. 1969. Energy conservation as simultaneous discovery. In: Critical Problems in the History of Science, edited by Marshall Clagett, 321-356. Madison: University of Wisconsin Press.
Liang, John. 1825. A Voyage to Spitzbergen. Edinburgh: Balfour and Clark.
MacDonald, John. 1822. On the north-west magnetic pole. Gentleman's Magazine 92: 209-214.
MacDonald, John. 1826. On polar magnetic attraction. Gentleman's Magazine 96: 120-127.
Martin, Constance. 1988. William Scoresby Jr. and the open polar sea—myth and reality. Arctic 41: 39-47.
Maury, Matthew. 1855. The Physical Geography of the Sea. New York: Harper and Brothers.
Mayer, Tobias. 1775. De variationibus thermometri accuratius definiendis. In: Opera Inedita, edited by Georg Christoph Lichtenberg 1: 3-10. Göttingen: Dieterich.
Morgan, S. R. 1990. Schelling and the origins of his Naturphilosophie. In: Romanticism and the Sciences edited by Andrew Cunningham and Nicholas Jardine, 25-37. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Murchison, Roderick. 1853. Address—Arctic discovery. Journal of the Royal Geographical Society 23: lxxv-lxxx.
Nielsen, Keld. 1991. The work of T. J. Seebeck and his collaboration with Goethe, Part 2. Historical Studies in the Physical and Biological Sciences 21: 317-397.
Oersted, Hans Christian. 1820. Experiments on the effect of a current of electricity on the magnetic needle. Annals of Philosophy 16: 273-276.
Osburn, Sherard. 1852. Stray Leaves from an Arctic Journal. New York: George Putnam.
P., T 1844. List of contributors to the Quarterly Review. Gentleman's Magazine 21: 137-141, 577-580.
Parry, William Edward. 1821. Journal of a Voyage for the Discovery of a North-west Passage. London: John Murray.
Parry, William Edward. 1828. Narrative of an Attempt to reach the North Pole. London: John Murray.
Petermann, August. 1852. The Search for Franklin. London: Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans.
Petermann, August. 1865a. Die Eisverhältnisse in den Polar-Meeren und die Möglichkeit des Vordringens in Schiffen bis zu den höchsten Breiten. Mittheilungen aus Justus Perthes' Geographischer Anstalt. 11: 136-146.
Petermann, August. 1865b. The expedition to the North Pole. The Reader. 5: 195.
Prévost, Pierre. 1826. The magnetical influence of the Sun. Edinburgh New Philosophical Journal 1: 289-291.
Purchas, Samuel. 1625. Hakluytus Posthumus, or Purchas his Pilgrimes. 20 vols. London: Henry Fetherston.
Reiss, Peter and Moser, Ludwig 1830. On the magnetic influence of the solar rays. Edinburgh Journal of Science 2: 225-229.
Robinson, Michael. 2006. Reconsidering the theory of the open polar sea. In: Extremes: Oceanography's Adventures at the Poles, edited by Keith Benson and Helen Rozwadowski, 15-29. Sagamore Beach, MA: Science History Publications.
Sabine, Edward. 1821. Account of Captain Parry's discoveries in the polar regions. Quarterly Journal of Science, Literature and the Arts 10: 355-361.
Savours, Ann. 1984. A very interesting point in geography. Arctic 37: 402-428.
Scoresby Jr, William. 1818. On the Greenland or polar ice. Memoirs of the Wernerian Natural History Society 2: 261-338.
Scoresby Jr, William. 1820. An Account of the Arctic Regions. Edinburgh: Constable and Co.
Seebeck, Thomas. 1822/1823. Magnetische Polarisation der Metalle und Erze durch Temperatur-Differenz. Abhandlungen der Königlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin 1: 265-373.
Shelley, Mary. 1963. Frankenstein. New York: Signet.
Snelders, H. A. M. 1990. Oersted's discovery of electromagnetism. In: Romanticism and the Sciences, edited by Andrew Cunningham and Nicholas Jardine, 228-240. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Somerville, Mary. 1826. On the magnetizing power of the more refrangible solar rays. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 116: 132-139.
Somerville, Mary. 1846. On the Connexion of the Physical Sciences. London: J. Murray.
Sutherland, Peter. 1852. Journal of a Voyage. 2 vols. London: Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans.
Tammiksaar, E., Sukhova, N. G., and Stone, I. R. 1999. Hypothesis versus fact: August Petermann and polar research. Arctic 52: 237-244.
Taylor, E. G. R. 1956. A letter dated 1577 from Mercator to John Dee. Imago mundi 13: 56-68.
Traill, Thomas. 1824. On thermo-magnetism. Edinburgh Philosophical Journal 11: 258-263.
Tuan, Yi-Fu. 1995. Desert and ice: ambivalent aesthetics. In: Landscape, Natural Beauty, and the Arts, edited by Salim Kemal and Ivan Gaskell, 139-157. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Veer, Gerrit de. 1876. Three Voyages of William Barents. London: Hakluyt Society.
Verne, Jules. 1876. The Voyages and Adventures of Captain Hatteras. Boston: James Osgood and Company.
Villarejo, Oscar. 1965. Dr. Kane's Voyage to the Polar Lands. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press.
Williams, Glyndwr. 1962. The British Search for the Northwest Passage in the Eighteenth Century. Plymouth: Bowering Press.
Wrangell, Frederick. 1840. Narrative of an Expedition to the Polar Sea, translated by Elizabeth Sabine. London: James Madden and Co.
Wright, John. 1953. The open polar sea. Geographical Review 43: 338-365.