Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 04 Apr 2013
Alexandre Brongniart (1770-1847) Shows that a ‘FActs First’ Scientific Approach Can Lead to Large-Scale Conclusions
Alexandre Brongniart (1770-1847) Shows that a ‘FActs First’ Scientific Approach Can Lead to Large-Scale Conclusions
Full access
Page Range: 9 – 22
The early nineteenth century has been described as a time of ‘Positive Geology’. The goal was to pursue fieldwork and build the edifice of science on ‘facts,’ thereby displacing the theorizing of previous centuries. French naturalists contributed prominently to the evolution of geoscience in that era. Georges Cuvier (1769-1832) and Alexandre Brongniart (1770-1847) were among the researchers who adhered to the ‘Facts First’ approach to understanding nature. Brongniart is an exemplar of the dedicated empiricist, careful observer, and cautious writer who was able to see ways to synthesize facts into conclusions of far-reaching consequence. The result is that collection and description of fossils, and observation of field relationships of rock units, led to an appreciation of the theoretical power of biotic succession, biostratigraphy, the geologic column, and geologic mapping.
Bork, Kennard B. 1981. Cross-channel currents: eighteenth-century French-language responses to British theories of the earth. Histoire et nature 19-20: 37-49.
Bork, Kennard B. 1986. Brongniart, Alexandre. In: Encyclopedia of Earth Sciences, E. Julius Dasch, editor in Chief, Vol. 1: 59-61. New York: Macmillan Reference USA.
Bork, Kennard B. 1999. Correspondence as a window on the development of a discipline: Brongniart, Cleaveland, Silliman and the maturation of mineralogy in the first decades of the nineteenth century. Earth Sciences History 18: 198-245.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1800. Essai d'une classification naturelle des reptiles. Bulletin de la Société Philomatique 2: 81-82, 89-91.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1807. Traité élémentaire de minéralogie, avec des applications aux arts: ouvrage destiné à l'enseignement dans les lycées nationaux, 2 vols. Paris: Chez Déterville.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1810. Sur les terrains qui paraissent avoir été formés sous l'eau douce. Annales du Muséum d'histoire naturelle 15, 357-405.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1813. Essai d'une clasification minéralogique des roches mélangées. Paris: Bossande.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1814. Notice sur l'histoire géognostique du Cotentin. Journal des mines No. 206, 3-19.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1821. Sur le gisement: ou, position relative des ophiolites, euphotides, jaspes, etc., dans quelques parties des Apennins. Paris: Imprimerie de Madame Huzard.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1822. Sur les caractères zoologiques des formations: avec l'application de ces caractères à la détermination de quelques terrains de craie. Paris: Imprimerie de Madame Huzard.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1823. Mémoire sur les terrains de sédiment supérieurs calcaro-trappéens du Vicentin, et sur quelques terrains d'Italie, de France, d'Allemagne, etc., qui peuvent se rapporter à la měme époque. Paris: F.-G. Levrault.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1827. Classification et caractères minéralogiques des roches homogènes et hétérogènes. Paris: F.-G. Levrault.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1828. Notice sur les blocs des roches des terrains de transport en Suède. Annales des sciences naturelles, 14, 5-22.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1829a. Des volcans et des terains volcaniques. Paris: F.-G. Levrault.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1829b. Tableau des terrains qui composent l'écorce du globe, ou essai sur la structure de la partie connue de la terre. Paris: F.-G. Levrault.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1839. Premier mémoire sur les kaolin ou argiles à porcelaine, sur la nature, le gisement, l'origine et l'emploi de cet sorte d'argile. Paris: Gide.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1841. Second mémoire sur les kaolin ou argiles à porcelaine, sur la nature, le gisement, l'origine et l'emploi de cet sorte d'argile. Paris: Gide.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1844. Traité des arts céramiques, ou des poteries: considérées dans leur histoire, leur pratique et leur théorie. Paris: Bechet jeune.
Brongniart, Alexandre. 1845. Description méthodique du Musée céramique de la manufacture royal de Porcelain de Sèvres. Paris: A. Leleux. Brongniart, Alexandre. n.d. Essai sur les couleurs obtenues des oxydes métalliques, et fixées par la fusion sur les différens corps vitreux.
Brongniart, Alexandre and Desmarest, Anselme-Gaëtan. 1822. Histoire naturelle des crustacés fossiles, sous les rapports zoologiques et géologiques: savoir les trilobites [Alexandre Brongniart] et les crustacés proprement dits [Anselme-Gaëtan Desmarest]. Paris: F.-G. Levrault.
Brongniart, Alexandre. Translations into English: 1823. On the Fresh-water Formations of Italy, Posterior to the Coarse Limestone. Edinburgh: A. Constable.
Brongniart, Alexandre. Translations into English: 1823. (with Cuvier). On Fossil Organic Remains as a Geognostic Character. Edinburgh: A. Constable.
Brongniart, Alexandre. Translations into English: 1824. A Selection of the Geological Memoirs Contained in the Annales des Mines: Together with a Synoptical Table of Equivalent Formations and M. Brongniart's Table of the Classification of Mixed Rocks, edited by Henry T. De La Beche. London: William Phillips.
Brongniart, Alexandre. Translations into English: 1836. Table of the Classification of the Mixed Rocks. Selection of geologic memoirs 1. London: W. Phillips.
Brongniart, Alexandre. Translations into English: 1836. On the Relative Position of the Serpentines (Ophiolites, Diallage Rocks [Euphotides], Jasper, &c.) in Some Parts of the Apeninnes. Selection of geologic memoirs 13. London: W. Phillips.
Brongniart, Alexandre. Translations into English: 1836. On the Zoological Characters of Formations, with the Application of these Characters to the Determination of Some Rocks of the Chalk Formation. Selection of Geologic Memoirs 17. London: W. Phillips.
Brongniart, Alexandre. Translations into English: 1836. On the Calcareo-trappean Formations of the Southern Foot of the Lombard Alps. Selection of Geologic Memoirs 19. London: W. Phillips.
Buffon, G. L. Leclerc de. 1749. Histoire naturelle, générale et particulière, avec la description du Cabinet du Roi. Paris: Imprimerie Royale.
Burnet, Thomas. 1684. The Sacred Theory of the Earth: Containing an Account of its Original Creation, and of all the General Changes which it Hath Undergone, or is to Undergo, until the Consummation of all Things. London: R. Norton.
Cleaveland, P. C. 1816. An Elementary Treatise on Mineralogy and Geology. Being an Introduction to the Study of these Sciences, and Designed for the Use of Pupils,— for Persons, Attending Lectures of these Subjects,—And as a Companion for Travellers in the United States of America. Boston: Cummings and Hilliard.
Cuvier, Georges. 1812. Recherches sur les ossemens fossiles de quadrupèdes: où l'on rétablit les caractères de plusieurs espèces d'animaux que les révolutions du globe paroissent avoir détruites. Les os fossiles des environs de Paris. Paris: Chez Déterville.
Cuvier, Georges and Brongniart, Alexandre. 1808. Essai sur la géographie minéralogique des environs de Paris. Journal des mines 23: 421-458. (Also: Annales du Muséum d'histoire naturelle 11: 299-328.)
Cuvier, Georges and Brongniart, Alexandre. 1811. Essai sur la géographie minéralogique des environs de Paris, avec une carte géognostique, et des coupes de terrain. Paris: Baudouin.
Cuvier, Georges and Brongniart, Alexandre. 1822. Description géologique des environs de Paris. Nouvelle édition, dans laquelle on a inséré la déscription d'un grand nombre de lieux de l'Allemagne, de la Suisse, de l'Italie, etc., qui presentent des terrains analogues à ceux du bassin de Paris, par M. Alex. Brongniart. Paris and Amsterdam: G. Dufour et E. d'Ocagne.
Cuvier, Georges and Brongniart, Alexandre. 1835. Déscription géologique des environs de Paris, 3. édition. Paris: E. d'Ocagne.
De Launay, Louis. 1940. Les Brongniart: une grande famille de savants. Paris: G. Rapilly et fils.
Druène, Bernard. 1987. L'aventure pyrénéenne d'Alexandre Brongniart, 1793-1794. Pau: Marrimpouey jeune.
Ellenberger, François. 1999. History of Geology: The Great Awakening and its First Fruits: 1660-1810, edited by Marguerite Carozzi. Rotterdam, Netherlands: A. A. Balkema.
Eyles, Joan M. 1985. Smith, Banks and the French geologists. In: From Linnaeus to Darwin: Commentaries on the History of Biology and Geology, edited by Alwyne Wheeler and James H. Price, 37-50. London: Society for the History of Natural History.
Gohau, Gabriel. 1978. Constant Prévost et le "géologie positive". Travaux du Comité Français d'Histoire de la Géologie (COFRHIGEO) No. 9: 1-6.
Gohau, Gabriel. 1990. A History of Geology, revised and translated by A. V. Carozzi. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press.
Gosselet, J. 1896. Constant Prévost. In: Annales de la Société Géologique du Nord 25: 1-34. Lille: Imprimerie Liégois-Six.
Gould, Stephen J. 1977. The Reverend Thomas Burnet's Dirty Little Planet. In: Ever Since Darwin, 141-146. New York: W. W. Norton & Co.
Hutton, James. 1795. Theory of the Earth, With Proofs and Illustrations. 2 vols. Edinburgh: William Creech.
Laudan, Rachel. 1987. From Mineralogy to Geology: The Foundation of a Science, 1650-1830. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Magruder, Kerry V. 2000. Theories of the Earth From Descartes to Cuvier: Natural Order and Historical Contingency in a Contested Textual Tradition. PhD dissertation, University of Oklahoma, Norman.
Magruder, Kerry V. 2006. Global visions and the establishment of Theories of the Earth. Centaurus 48: 234-257.
Magruder, Kerry V. and Taylor, Kenneth L. 2004. Theories of the Earth. In: Theories of the Earth, edited by Jonathan Dewald, Vol. 2, 222-226. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
Merrill, George P. 1906. Contributions to the History of American Geology. Washington, D. C.: U. S. Government Printing Office.
Poole, William. 2010. The World Makers: Scientists of the Restoration and the Search for the Origins of the Earth. Oxford: Peter Lang.
Préaud, Tamara. 1997. The Sèvres Porcelain Manufactory: Alexandre Brongniart and the Triumph of Art and Industry, 1800-1847. New Haven: Yale University Press
Ray, John. 1691. The Wisdom of God Manifested in the Works of Creation. London: Printed for Samuel Smith.
Ray, John. 1693. Three Physico-Theological Discourses. London: Printed for Samuel Smith.
Roger, Jacques. 1973. La théorie de la terre au XVIIe siècle. Revue d'histoire des sciences 26: 23-48.
Rudwick, M. J. S. 1970. Brongniart, Alexandre. In: Dictionary of Scientific Biography, edited by Charles C. Gillispie, Vol. 2, 493-497. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons.
Rudwick, M. J. S. 1996. Cuvier and Brongniart, William Smith, and the reconstruction of geohistory. Earth Sciences History 15: 25-36.
Schneer, Cecil J. 1969. Introduction. In: Toward a History of Geology, edited by Cecil J. Schneer, 1-18. Cambridge, MA: M. I. T. Press.
Taquet, Philippe, 2009a. Geology beyond the channel: the beginnings of geohistory in early nineteenth-century France. In: The Making of the Geological Society of London, Geological Society of London Special Publication 317, edited by C. L. E. Lewis and S. J. Knell, 155-162. London: The Geological Society of London.
Taquet, Philippe, 2009b. Les contributions respectives de Georges Cuvier et d'Alexandre Brongniart à l'élaboration de l'Essai sur la géographie minéralogique des environs de Paris, d'après les manuscrits retrouvés d'Alexandre Brongniart. Travaux du Comité français d'histoire de la géologie (COFRHIGEO). Troisième série 23, No. 1: 1-16.
Taquet, Philippe. 2012. Personal communication about the recent finding of Alexandre Brongniart's personal journals from 1790 to 1802. Web-search for Le journal retrouvé d'Alexandre Brongniart (1790-1802).
Whiston, William. 1696. A New Theory of the Earth, From its Original, to the Consummation of All Things, Wherein the Creation of the World in Six Days, the Universal Deluge, and the General Conflagration, as Laid Down in the Holy Scriptures are Shewn to be Perfectly Agreeable to Reason and Philosophy. With a Large Introductory Discourse Concerning the Genuine Nature, Stile and Extent of the Mosaick History of the Creation. London: R. Roberts for Benjamin Tooke.
Woodward, John. 1695. An Essay Toward a Natural History of the Earth and Terrestrial bodies, Especially Minerals, As Also of the Sea, Rivers, and Springs, With an Account of the Universal Deluge, and of the Effects it had upon the Earth. London: Richard Wilkin.