Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | 
Online Publication Date: 17 Jan 2013

Richard Kirwan (1733-1812)

Page Range: 287 – 314
DOI: 10.17704/eshi.31.2.7151vv24h27u5494
Save
Download PDF

Kirwan's life can be seen as a succession of phases whose boundaries were flexible. Born to a Catholic, land-owning family in Ireland, his youth and education were very much a product of those conditions, which in his case included higher education in France. After his return to Ireland and marriage, he spent time in Ireland, England, and on the Continent. During that period he studied law, the practice of which required his conforming to the Irish Anglican Church, now better known as the (Protestant) Established Church of Ireland. After a first (to his mind) unsuccessful effort at chemistry, but finding law practice unrewarding, he returned to chemistry, which included mineralogy. His stellar decade in London from 1777 to 1787 followed, during which time his chemistry earned him the Copley Medal of the Royal Society and he emerged as one of the leading advocates of phlogiston, backed by reasoning that many found compelling. He returned to Ireland in 1787 and lived in Dublin until his death. His interest in chemistry continued, but geology became his focus as he challenged James Hutton's (1796-1797) theory of the Earth, basing his arguments in part on his laboratory experience with rocks and minerals. A position as Irish Inspector of Mines revealed his experience with practical geology and fieldwork. Although he continued with technical publications fairly regularly until 1803, and sporadically thereafter, he became more philosophical and published on languages, space, and time. He was elected President of the Royal Irish Academy, a position that he held from 1799 until his death in 1812.

Beaumont, G. de. [1839] 2006. Ireland, Social, Political, and Religious. Edited and translated by W. C. Taylor. Cambridge MA: The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press.

Boantza, V. D. 2008. The phlogistic role of heat in the Chemical Revolution and the origins of Kirwan's "Ingenious modifications into the theory of phlogiston". Annals of Science 65: 309-338.

Boantza, V. D., and O. Gal. 2011. The ‘absolute existence’ of phlogiston: the losing party's point of view. British Journal for the History of Science 44: 317-342.

Brooke, W. 1813. A Catalogue of Books Bequeathed by the late Richard Kirwan Esq. to the Royal Irish Academy. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy Library Ms. 3A6.

Brown, B. T. 1999. Volcanoes unbound? The reception of French Geological research by the Irish mineralogist, Richard Kirwan, 1733-1812. In: Garrioch (ed.), 1999, pp. 245-260.

Burns, B. T. 2003. Richard Kirwan, 1733-1812: "The Philosopher of Dublin". National Committee for the History and Philosophy of Science, 8th Annual Lecture. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy.

Cavendish, H. 1784a. Experiments on air. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 74: 119-153.

Cavendish, H. 1784b. Answer to Mr. Kirwan's remarks upon the experiments on air. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 74, 170-177.

Chillingworth, W. 1638. The Religion of Protestants: A Safe Way to Salvation or AN ANSWER to a Booke Entitled Mercy and Truth, or, Charity Maintain'd by Catholiques, Which Pretends to Prove the Contrary. Oxford: Printed by Leonard Lichfield.

Curtis, E. [1936] 2002. A History of Ireland from Earliest Times to 1922. London and New York: Routledge, Taylor and Francis.

Davis, W. J. 2000. William James McNeven: chemist and United Irishman. In: Wyse Jackson (2000: 7-24).

Dixon, F. E. 1971. Richard Kirwan: the Dublin philosopher. Dublin Historical Record 24: 53-64.

Dolan, B. 2004. Wedgwood: The First Tycoon. New York: The Viking Press.

Donovan, M. 1850. A biographical account of the late Richard Kirwan, Esq. LLD. Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy 4: lxxxi-cxviii.

Eklund, J. 1975. The Incompleat Chymist. Smithsonian Studies in History and Technology 33: Washington D. C.: Smithonian Institution Press.

Epstein, J. [2008] 2009. Alexis de Tocqueville, Democracy's Guide. New York: Harper Perennial.

Garrioch, D. (ed). 1999 The Culture of the Book: Essays from Two Hemispheres in Honour of Wallace Kirsop. Melbourne: Bibliographic Society of Australia and New Zealand.

Gillispie, C. C. [1951] 1959. Genesis and Geology. New York: Harper Torchbooks, Harper & Row.

Grison, E., M. Goupil and P. Bret (eds). 1994. A Scientific Correspondence During the French Revolution: Louis-Bernard Guyton de Morveau and Richard Kirwan, 1782-1802. Berkeley: University of California at Berkeley.

Hall, J. 1794. Observations on the formation of granite. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 3: 8-12.

Hall, J. 1805. Experiments on whinstone and lava. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 5: 43-76.

Hutton, J. 1794. Observations on granite. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 3: 77-85.

[Jeffrey, F.] 1802. Review of J. Playfair's Illlustration of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth, Edinburgh Review 1: 201-216.

Kirwan, R. 1780. In: C. W. Scheele, Chemical Observations and Experiments on Air and Fire. Introduction by T. O. Begman; Translated by J. R. Forster, with Notes by R. Kirwan. London: printed for J. Johnson. (Comments on Scheele's experiments, notes his own and Priestley's and those of a number of others.)

Kirwan, R. 1781. Experiments and observations on the specific gravities and attractive powers of various saline substances. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 71: 7-41.

Kirwan, R. 1782. Continuation of the experiments and observations on the specific gravities and attractive powers of various saline substances. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 72: 179-236.

Kirwan, R. 1783. Conclusion of the experiments and observaions concerning the attractive powers of the mineral acids. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 73: 15-84.

Kirwan, R. 1784a. Elements of Mineralogy. London: printed for P. Elmsly.

Kirwan, R. 1784b. Remarks on Mr. Cavendish's experiments on air. In a letter from Richard Kirwan, Esq. F. R. S., to Sir Joseph Banks, Bart., F. R. S., Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 74: 154-169.

Kirwan, R. 1784c. Reply to Mr. Cavendish's answer. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 74: 178-180.

Kirwan, R. 1785, Remarks on specific gravities taken at different degrees of heat, and an easy method of reducing them to a common standard. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 75: 267-271.

Kirwan, R. 1786. Experiments on hepatic air. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 76: 118-154.

Kirwan, R. 1787. An Estimate of the Temperatures at Different Latitudes. London: J. Davis for P. Elmsley.

Kirwan, R. 1787. An Essay on Phlogiston and the Constitution of Acids. London: J. Johnson.

Kirwan, R. 1789a An Essay on Phlogiston and the Constitution of Acids. A New Edition. To which are Added Notes Exhibiting and Definding the Antiphlogistic Theory; and Annexed to the French Edition of the Work, by Messrs. de Morveau, Lavoisier, de la Place, Monge, Berthollet, and de Fourcroy Translated into English. London: J. Johnson. Reprinted 1968.

Kirwan, R. 1789b. Experiments on the alkaline substances used in bleaching, and on the colouring matter of linen-yarn. TRIA 3: 3-47.

Kirwan, R. 1789c. Beantwortung einiger Einwürfe gegen die Theorie von der Wärme. Chemische Annalen 1: 198-202.

Kirwan, R. 1790. Observations on coal mines. TRIA 3: 157-170.

Kirwan, R. 1791a. Of the strength of acids, and the proportion of ingredients in neutral salts. TRIA 4: 13-84.

Kirwan, R. 1791b. Über die Regeln des Raisonnements in der Naturlehre. Chemische Annalen 2: 3-13, 103-117.

Kirwan, R. 1793. On the calculation of heights by barometers. Anthologica hibernica 1: 203-206.

Kirwan, R. 1794a. Elements of Mineralogy. 2nd edn. London: P. Elmsley.

Kirwan, R. 1794b. A comparative view of meteorological observations made in Ireland since the year 1788, with some hints towards forming prognostics of the weather. TRIA 5: 3-29.

Kirwan, R. 1794c. Examination of the supposed igneous origin of stony substances. TRIA 5: 51-81.

Kirwan, R. 1794d. What are the Manures most Advantageously Applicable to the Various Sorts of Soils, and [What are] the Causes of their Beneficial Effect in Each Particular Instance. Dublin: Graisberry & Campbell. Also in TRIA and many other editions.

Kirwan, R. 1794e. Experiments on a new earth found near Stronthian, in Scotland. TRIA 5: 243-255.

Kirwan, R. 1797a. On the composition and proportion of carbon in bitumens and mineral coal. TRIA 6: 141-167.

Kirwan, R. 1797b. Thoughts on magnetism. TRIA 6: 177-191.

Kirwan, R. 1797c. On the primitive state of the globe and its subsequent catastrophe. TRIA 6: 233-308.

Kirwan, R. 1799a. Geological Essays. London: T. Bensley for D. Bremner.

Kirwan, R. 1799b. An Essay on the Analysis of Mineral Waters. London: J. W. Myers for D. Bremner.

Kirwan, R. 1800a. Additional observations on the proportion of real acid in the three antient known mineral acids, and on the ingredients in various neutral salts, and other compounds. TRIA 7: 163-297.

Kirwan, R. 1800b. A plan for the introduction and establishment of the most advantageous management of mines in the kingdom of Ireland. Transactions of the Dublin Society 1, Part 1: 277-284; 1802. Part 2: 245-251.

Kirwan, R. 1800c. Names of vegetables employed in different countries, instead of bark, for tanning leather. Transactions of the Dublin Society 1: 286.

Kirwan, R. 1800d. Essay on human liberty. TRIA 7, 305-316. Also in Metaphysical Essays 1809: 149-162.

Kirwan, R. 1801. Easy methods of estimating the richness of milk, and the strength of wine, beer, and spirits. Transactions of the Dublin Society 2: 340-342.

Kirwan, R. 1802a. Observations on the report of the gold mines in the County of Wicklow. Transactions of the Dublin Society 2: 149-157.

Kirwan, R. 1802b. Observations on the proofs on the Huttonian theory of the Earth, adduced by Sir James Hall, Bart. TRIA 8: 3-27.

Kirwan, R. 1802c. An illustration and confirmation of some facts mentioned in an essay on the primitive state of the globe. TRIA 8: 29-34.

Kirwan, R. 1802d. An essay on the declivities of mountains. TRIA 8, 35-52.

Kirwan, R. 1802e. Of chymical and mineralogical nomenclature. TRIA, 53-76.

Kirwan, R. 1802f. A reply to Mr. Playfair's reflections on Mr. Kirwan's refutation of the Huttonian theory of the Earth. Philosophical Magazine 14: 3-13.

Kirwan, R. 1802g. Remarks on some sceptical positions in Mr. Hume's Enquiry Concerning the Human Understanding and his Treatise of Human Nature.TRIA 8: 157-201.

Kirwan, R. 1806a. On space and duration. TRIA 10: 189-214. Also in Metaphysical Essays 1809: 97-131.

Kirwan, R. 1806b. Of duration, time and eternity. TRIA 10: 215-229. Also in Metaphysical Essays 1809: 131-148.

Kirwan, R. 1806c. On the primeval language of mankind. TRIA 10: 121-176.

Kirwan, R. 1807. Logick: Or an Essay on the Elements, Principles and Different Modes of Reasoning, 2 vols. London.

Kirwan, R. 1809. Metaphysical Essays: Containing the Principles and Fundamental Objects of that Science. 2nd edn 1811. London: J. Macinley.

Kirwan, R. 1810a. Description of a new anemometer. TRIA 11: 61-68.

Kirwan, R. 1810b. An essay on happiness. TRIA 11: 3-188.

Kirwan, R. 1810c. Of the origin of polytheism, idolatry, and Grecian mythology. TRIA 11: 3-61.

Kölbl-Ebert, M. (ed.). 2009. Geology and Religion: A History of Harmony and Hostility. London: The Geological Society.

Levere, T. H, and G. L'E. Turner. 2002. Discussing Chemistry and Steam. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Lewis, C. L. E. and S. J. Knell (eds). 2001. The Age of the Earth: From 4004 BC to AD 2002. London: The Geological Society of London.

Magellan, J. H. de. 1780. Essai sur la nouvelle théorie du feu élémentaire et de la chaleur des corps. London: P. Elmsley & W. Brown.

Mauskopf, S. 2002. Richard Kirwan's phlogiston theory: its success and fate. Ambix 49: 185-205.

Meenan, J. and D. Clarke (eds). 1981. The Royal Dublin Society 1731-1981. Dublin: Gill and Macmillan.

McKie, D. and N. H. de V. Heathcote. 1960 for 1958. William Cleghorn's De igne (1779). Annals of Science 14: 1-82.

McLaughlin, P. J. 1939. Richard Kirwan (1733-1812). Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review 28 I. 461-474; II. 593-605; 29, III. 71-83; IV. 281-300 (1940).

McLaughlin, P. J. 1954. The Kirwanian Society (1812). Studies: An Irish Quarterly Review 43: 441-450.

O'Flanagan, J. R. 1865. Richard Kirwan, L. L. D. F. R. S., P. R. I. A. The Dublin Saturday Magazine 2: 242-244, 254-256, 266-269.

Oldroyd, D. R. 1974. From Paracelsus to Haüy: The Development of Mineralogy in its Relation to Chemistry. PhD dissertaion, The University of New South Wales.

Oldroyd, D. R. 2009. Jean-André de Luc (1727-1817): an atheist's comparative view of the historiography. In: Kölbl-Ebert (2009: 7-16).

Newcomb, S. 2009. The World in a Crucible: Laboratory Practice and Geological Theory at the Beginning of Geology. Boulder: Geological Society of America.

Newcomb, S. 2011. Irish mining in Richard Kirwan's (1733-1812) time. In History of Research in Mineral Resources. Madrid: Instituto Geológico y Minero de España, 121-130.

Royal Dublin Society. 1931. Bicentenary Souvenier 1731-1931. Dublin: Browne and Nolan Ltd.

Rudwick, M. J. S. 2001. Jean-André de Luc and nature's chronology. In: Lewis and Knell (2001: 51-60).

Rudwick, M. J. S. 2005. Bursting the Limits of Time. Chicago and London: The University of Chicago Press.

Rudwick, M. J. S. 2009. Biblical Flood and geological deluge: the amicable dissociation of geology and Genesis. In: Kölbl-Ebert (2009: 103-110).

Scott, E. L. 1973. Richard Kirwan. Dictionary of Scientific Biography 7: 387-390.

Scott, E. L. 1979. The Life and Work of Richard Kirwan (1733-1812). Unpublished PhD thesis, University of London.

Scott, E. L. 1981. Richard Kirwan, J. H. de Magellan, and the early history of specific heat. Annals of Science 38: 141-153.

Sweet, J. M. 1967. Robert Jameson's Irish journal, 1797. Annals of Science 23: 97-125.

Taylor, G. 2008. Tracing influence in small steps: Richard Kirwan's quantified affinity theory. Ambix 55: 209-231.

Traxler-Brown, B. 1991. German life and letters as witnessed by the books of an Irish chemist, Dr. Richard Kirwan (1733-1812). In: Buch und Bibliothekswissenschaft imformationszeitalter, edited by E. Plassmann, W. Schmitz and P. Vodosek, 297-312. Munich: G. G. Saur.

Uglow, J. 2002. The Lunar Men. New York: Farrar, Straus and Giroux.

Wiggin, C. B. 1966. The Kirwan Collection at the Salem Athenaeum: With a Biographical Sketch of Richard Kirwan and History of Acquisition of the Collection. Newcomb & Gauss, Salem, Mass, pp. 26-36.

Wyse Jackson, P. N. 1998. Richard Kirwan (1733-1812): chemist and geologist. Irish Chemical News 12: 36-39.

Wyse Jackson, P. N. (ed.). 2000. Science and Engineering in Ireland in 1798: A Time of Revolution. Dublin: Royal Irish Academy.

  • Download PDF