Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
 | 
Online Publication Date: 21 Apr 2011

Religious assumptions in Lord Kelvin's estimates of the Earth's age

Page Range: 187 – 212
DOI: 10.17704/eshi.29.2.46678x0701k62j0j
Save
Download PDF

Lord Kelvin's estimates of the Earth's age were not necessary consequences of his physics. Religion influenced his physics and his arguments for a limited age of the Earth. Kelvin's primary aim was to destroy Charles Darwin's theory of evolution by natural selection by attacking the uniformitarian geology on which Darwin's theory was founded. His calculations of the age of the Earth contained a fundamental contradiction. He assumed that the Earth began as a hot liquid sphere, but Fourier's mathematics, which he used to calculate the rate of cooling, applied only to heat conducted through a solid. Kelvin's assumption of an initially hot liquid Earth was a necessary consequence of his thermodynamics. Energy could neither be created nor destroyed. The heat within the Earth must, therefore, be derived from its first creation by God. Kelvin never admitted the contradiction between the original hot liquid Earth and his calculation of its cooling on the assumption that the Earth was solid throughout, but in 1897 his imagined account of the initial Earth was a search for a solid Earth amenable to his calculations. The heat flow through the solid crust was very small in proportion to the total internal heat of the Earth. If Kelvin had included the total internal heat in his calculations, he would have arrived at much higher figures for the age of the Earth.

Airy, G. B. 1855. On the computation of the attraction of mountain masses, as disturbing the apparent astronomical latitude of stations in geodetic surveys. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 145: 101-104.

Anon. 1865. Objects of the Victoria Institute. Journal of the Victoria Institute 1: vi.

Bischof, Carl Gustav. 1843. Versuche, die Kontraktion zu bestimmen, welche geschmolzene Masse erleiden, wenn sie in den festen Zustand und Krystallinische Gesteine bilden. Newes Jahrbuch für Mineralogie, Geognosie, Geologie und Petrefakten Kunde, pp. 1-54.

Brown, Stewart J. 1982. Thomas Chalmers and the Godly Commonwealth in Scotland. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Brush, Stephen G. 1979. Nineteenth-century debates about the inside of the Earth: solid, liquid or gas? Annals of Science 36: 225-254.

Burchfield, Joe D. 1975. Lord Kelvin and the Age of the Earth. New York: Science History Publications.

Carnot, Sadi. 1824. Réflections sur la puissance motrice du feu et sur les machines propres à développer cette puissance. Paris.

Cavendish, Henry. 1798. Experiments to determine the density of the earth. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 88: 469-526.

Chalmers, Thomas. 1817. A Series of discourses on the Christian Revelation, Viewed in Connection with the Modern Astronomy. Glasgow: J. Smith; London: Longman, Hurst, Rees, Orme, and Brown.

Chalmers, Thomas. 1848. Selected Works. 4 vols. New York: Robert Carter.

Chamberlin, Thomas Chrowder. 1899. Lord Kelvin's address on the age of the Earth as an abode fitted for life. Science 9: 889-901; 10: 11-18.

Clapeyron, B. P. E. 1834. Mémoire sur la puissance motrice de la chaleur. Journal de l'École Polytechnique 14: 153-190.

Cockburn, Henry. 1874. Memorials of his Time. Edinburgh: Adam and Charles Black.

Cordier, Pierre. 1827. Essai sur la température de l'intérieur de la terre. Mémoires de l'Académie des Sciences, Paris 7: 473-556.

Daniell, John Frederic. 1830. On a new register pyrometer for measuring the expansion of solids and determining the higher degrees of temperature upon the common thermometric scale. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London, Part 2: 257-286.

Darwin, Charles. 1859. On the Origin of Species by Means of Natural Selection. London: John Murray.

Gray, Andrew. 1908. Lord Kelvin: An Account of His Scientific Life and Work. London: J. M. Dent Co.; New York: E. P. Dutton & Co.

Hanna, William. 1852. Memoirs of the Life and Writings of Thomas Chalmers. 3 vols. New York: Harper & Brothers.

Holmes, Andrew W. 2008. Presbyterians and science in the north of Ireland before 1874. British Journal for the History of Science 41: 541-565.

Hutton, Charles. 1778. An account of the calculations made from the survey and measures taken at Schiehallien, in order to ascertain the mean density of the earth. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 68: 689-788.

Hutton, Charles. 1821. On the mean density of the earth. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 111: 276-292.

Hutton, James. [1785] 1788. Theory of the earth; or an investigation of the laws observable in the composition, dissolution and restoration of land upon the globe. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 1: 209-304.

Hutton, James. 1795. Theory of the Earth with Proofs and Illustrations. 2 vols. Edinburgh: Cadell and Davies.

Huxley, Thomas Henry. 1869. Anniversary address. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 25: xxxviii-liii.

Kahali, Mandipa. 1997. John Henry Pratt, Archdeacon of Calcutta and his theory of isostatic compensation. Indian Journal of History of Science 29: 23-30.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. [signed P. Q. R.] 1842. On the linear motion of heat. Cambridge Mathematical Journal 3: 140-174.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. [signed P. Q. R.] 1844. Notes on some points in the theory of heat. Cambridge Mathematical Journal 4: 67-72.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1852. On a universal tendency in nature to the dissipation of mechanical energy. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 3: 139-142.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. [1851] 1853. On the dynamical theory of heat; with numerical results deduced from Mr. Joule's "Equivalent of a thermal unit" and M. Regnault's "Observations on steam". Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 20: 261-288.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1854. On mechanical antecedents of motion, heat, and light. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 24: 59-63.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1861. Physical considerations regarding the probable age of the sun's heat. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 31: 27-28.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1863. On the rigidity of the earth. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 153: 573-582.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. [1862] 1864. On the secular cooling of the earth. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 23: 157-170.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1866. The "doctrine of uniformity" in geology briefly refuted. Proceedings of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 5: 512-513.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. [1868] 1871a. On geological time. Transactions of the Geological Society of Glasgow 3: 1-28.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. [1869] 1871b. On geological dynamics. Transactions of the Geological Society of Glasgow 3: 215-240.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1871c. Presidential address. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science (Edinburgh) 41: lxxxiv-cv.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1876-1880. The internal condition of the earth; as to temperature, fluidity, and rigidity. Transactions of the Geological Society of Glasgow 6: 38-49.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1895. The age of the earth. Nature 51: 438-440.

Kelvin, William Thomson, Baron. 1899. The age of the earth as an abode fitted for life [Victoria Institute Lecture, June 1897]. Journal of the Victoria Institute 31: 11-35.

King, Elizabeth. 1909. Lord Kelvin's Early Home. London: Macmillan and Co.

Laplace, Pierre-Simon. 1820. Sur la densité moyenne de la terre. Connaissance des temps, pp. 328-331.

Lyell, Charles. 1830-1833. Principles of Geology, Being an Attempt to Explain the Former Changes of the Earth's Surface by Reference to Causes Now in Operation. 3 vols. London: John Murray.

Lyell, Charles. 1834. Principles of Geology. 3rd edn. 4 vols. London: John Murray.

Lyell, Charles. 1853. Principles of Geology. 9th edn. Boston: Little, Brown, and Company.

Maskelyne, Nevil. 1775a. A proposal for measuring the attraction of some hill in this kingdom by astronomical observations. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 65: 495-499.

Maskelyne, Nevil. 1775b. An account of observations made on the mountain Schehallien for finding its attraction. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 65: 500-542.

Muirhead, Henry. 1878. Experiments on the relative specific gravities of solid and melted materials at the temperature of fusion. Nature 18: 397-398.

Paley, William. 1802. Natural Theology; or Evidence of the Existence and Attributes of the Deity Collected from the Appearances of Nature. London.

Poulton, E. B. 1896. A naturalist's contribution to the discussion upon the age of the earth. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 66: 808-828.

Perry, John. 1895a. On the age of the earth. Nature 51: 224-227.

Perry, John. 1895b. The age of the earth. Nature 51: 582-585.

Playfair, John. 1811. Account of a lithological survey of Schehallien, made in order to determine the specific gravity of the rocks which compose that mountain. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 101: 347-377.

Pratt, John Henry. 1855. On the attraction of the Himalaya Mountains, and of the elevated regions beyond them. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 145: 53-100.

Pratt, John Henry. 1859a. On the deflection of the plumb-line in India, caused by the attraction of the Himmalaya Mountains and of the elevated regions beyond; and its modification by the compensating effect of a deficiency of matter below the mountain mass. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 149: 745-778.

Pratt, J[ohn] H[enry]. 1859b. On the influence of the ocean on the plumb-line in India. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London 149: 779-796.

Pratt, John Henry. 1860. A Treatise on Attraction's Laplace's Functions, and the Figure of the Earth. Cambridge and London: Macmillan and Co.

Salisbury, Robert Cecil, Marquess of. 1894. Address. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science 64: 3-15.

Shipley, Brian C. 2001. Had Lord Kelvin a right? John Perry, natural selection and the age of the earth, 1894-1895. In: The Age of the Earth from 4004 BC to AD 2002, edited by C. L. E. Lewis and S. J. Knell, 91-105. Geological Society Special Publication, No. 190. London: Geological Society.

Smith, Crosbie. 1976. Natural philosophy and thermodynamics: William Thomson and "the dynamical theory of heat". British Journal for the History of Science 9: 293-319.

Smith, Crosbie. 1979. From design to dissolution: Thomas Chalmers' debt to John Robison. British Journal for the History of Science 12: 59-70.

Smith, Crosbie and Wise, M. Norton. 1989. Energy and Empire: A Biographical Study of Lord Kelvin. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Stacey, Frank D. 2000. Kelvin's age of the earth paradox revisited. Journal of Geophysical Research 105: 13,155-13,158.

Stokes, G. G. 1893. Natural Theology. The Gifford Lectures Delivered Before the University of Edinburgh in 1893. London: Adam and Charles Black.

Stokes, George Gabriel. 1990. The Correspondence between Sir George Gabriel Stokes and Sir William Thomson, Baron Kelvin of Largs, edited by David B. Wilson. 2 vols. Cambridge and New York: Cambridge University Press.

Thompson, Silvanus P. 1910. The Life of William Thomson, Baron Kelvin of Largs. 2 vols. London: Macmillan and Co.

Walcott, Charles D. 1893. Geologic time, as indicated by the sedimentary rocks of North America. Journal of Geology 1: 639-676.

Whewell, William. 1833. Astronomy and General Physics Considered with Reference to Natural Theology. London: W. Pickering.

Whitley, Joseph. 1879. [Communicated by Henry Muirhead] Experiments on the relative specific gravities of solid and melted metals etc., at the temperature of fusion. Proceedings of the Philosophical Society of Glasgow 11: 145-149.

Wilson, David B. 1974. Kelvin's scientific realism: the theological context. Philosophical Journal 11: 41-60.

  • Download PDF