Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 05 Nov 2007
Prototaxites Dawson, 1859 or Nematophycus Carruthers, 1872: Geologists V. Botanists in the Formative Period of the Science of Paleobotany
Prototaxites Dawson, 1859 or Nematophycus Carruthers, 1872: Geologists V. Botanists in the Formative Period of the Science of Paleobotany
Page Range: 35 – 61
A fossil plant found in the Devonian rocks of the Gaspé Peninsula of Canada provoked a heated debate in the late 19th century. When geologist John William Dawson identified it as an early land plant resembling a conifer (1859), he was challenged by botanist William Carruthers who argued it was a giant alga (1872). Until recently most scientists have tended to agree with Carruthers, but recent analysis suggest that neither Carruthers nor Dawson were fully correct. This paper focuses on the historical origins of the Prototaxites-Nematophycus debate, specifically on the role the debate played in the process of establishing methods within a new sub-field of paleontology. In large measure, Dawson and Carruthers disagreed over the identity and classification of this specimen because of their scientific training and areas of specialization. Carruthers and other botanists argued that the geologists who tended to dominate paleontology knew little about plant morphology and even less about the crucial identifying characteristics of the organs of fruitification. Alternatively, geologists, such as Dawson, had provided concepts and methods (eg. stratigraphy, mineralogy, geological time-scale) to paleontology, and they were not about to relinquish authority earned in previous decades.
Abbott, Geoff, Greg Ewbank, and Dianne Edwards, Lithological Control on the State of Preservation of Prototaxites. NRG News 98 Newcastle upon Tyne: Fossil Fuels and Environmental Geochemistry [Postgraduate Institute], 1998: 4-5. Available http://nrg.ncl.ac.uk/research/news/NRG%20news2098.pdf
Abbott, Geoff, Greg Ewbank, and Guang-Yu Wang. Molecular characterization of some enigmatic Lower Devonian fossils. Geochimica et Cosmochimica Acta 62(8), 1998:1407-1418.
Abbott, Geoff, Dianne Edwards, Trevor Drage and Christopher Vane. Molecular Characterization of Some of the Earliest Terrestrial Organisms. Journal of Conference Abstracts Goldschmidt 2000. 5, No.2, 2000:115.
Ami, Henry M. Sir John William Dawson: A Brief Biographical Sketch. American Geologist No.1, 26, 1900:1-55.
Andrews Jr., Henry N. Studies in Paleobotany (New York and London: John Wiley and Sons Inc., 1961).
Andrews Jr., Henry N. Ancient Plants and the World they Lived In (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1965).
Andrews Jr., Henry N. Index of Generic Names of Fossil Plants, 1820-1965. Geological Survey Bulletin 1300, Based on the Compendium Index of Paleobotany of the U.S. Geological Survey. Washington, D.C.: US Government Printing Office, 1970.
Andrews Jr., Henry N. The Fossil Hunters: In Search of Ancient Plants (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 1980).
Arber, E. A. Newell. Devonian Floras: A Study of the Origins of Cormophyta (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1921).
Arnold, Chester A. A Specimen of Prototaxites from the Kettle Point Black Shale of Ontario. Palaeontographica B Series 93, 1952:52.
Bell, W. A. Catalogue of Types and Figured Specimens of Fossil Plants in the Geological Survey of Canada Collections (Ottawa: Department of Mines and Technical Surveys, 1962).
Berger, Carl. Science, God, and Nature in Victorian Canada. The 1982 Joanne Goodman Lectures (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1983).
Bowler, Peter J. Fossils and Progress: Paleontology and the Idea of Progressive Revolution in the Nineteenth Century (New York: Science History, 1976).
Bowler, Peter J. The Fontana History of the Environmental Sciences (London: Fontana Press, 1992).
Britten, James. In Memory of William Carruthers (1830-1922), Journal of Botany, British and Foreign 60, 1922:249-256.
Carruthers, William. Review of J.W. Dawson, Acadian Geology: The Geological Structure, Organic Remains, and Mineral Resources of Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Prince Edward Island. Second Ed. (London: Macmillan and Co., 1868) in Geological Magazine 5, 1868:329-337.
Carruthers, William. On the Structure and Affinities of Sigillaria and allied genera, Geological Magazine 6, 1869:224.
Carruthers, William. The Crytogamic Forests of the Coal Period, Geological Magazine 6, 1869:289-300.
Carruthers, William. On Some Undescribed Coniferous Fruits from the Secondary Rocks of Britain." Geological Magazine 6, 1869:1-7.
Carruthers, William. On Beania, a new genus of Cycadean fruit, from the Yorkshire Oolites. Geological Magazine 6, 1869:97-99.
Carruthers, William. On the Plant Remains from the Brazilian Coal Beds, with remarks on the genus Flemingites. Geological Magazine 6, 1869:151-155.
Carruthers, William. The Cryptogamic Forests of the Coal Period, Geological Magazine 6, 1869:289-300.
Carruthers, William. On the fossil Cycadean stems from the secondary rocks of Britain, Transactions of the Linnean Society of London 26, 1870:675-708.
Carruthers, William. On Two Undescribed Coniferous Fruits from the Secondary Rocks of Britain. Geological Magazine 8, 1871:540-544.
Carruthers, William. On the history, histological structure, and affinities of Nematophycus Logani, Carr. (Prototaxites Logani, Dawson), an alga of Devonian age. Monthly Microscopical Journal: Transactions of the Royal Microscopical Society and Record of Histological Research 8, 1872:160-172.
Carruthers, William. Nematophycus or Prototaxites? Monthly Microscopical Journal: Transactions of the Royal Microscopical Society and Record of Histological Research 10, 1873:208-210.
Cleal, Christopher J. and Barry A. Thomas. Plant Fossils: The History of Land Vegetation (Woodbridge, UK and Rochester, NY: Boydell Press, 1999).
Dawson, John William [J. W.] On the Lower Carboniferous or Gypsiferous Formation of Nova Scotia. Proceedings of the Geological Society 4, 1843:272-281.
Dawson, John William [J. W.] On Fossil Plants from the Devonian Rocks of Canada. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London 15, 1859:477-88. [also published as Flora of the Devonian Period in North-Eastern America, Proceedings, Geological Society of London, 1862.]
Dawson, John William [J. W.] Further observations on the Devonian Plants of Maine, Gaspe and New York. Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society of London, 1863:458-469.
Dawson, John William [J. W.] The Fossil Plants of the Devonian and Upper Silurian Formations of Canada (Montreal: Geological Survey of Canada, 1871).
Dawson, John William [J. W.] On the Bearing of Devonian Botany on questions as to the Origin and Extinction of Species, American Journal of Science 2, 1871:410-416.
Dawson, John William [J. W.] The Story of Earth and Man. (1873) 12th edition (London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1898).
Dawson, John William [J. W.] Remarks on Mr. Carruther's [sic] views of Prototaxites.[offprint] Monthly Microscopical Journal, August 1873:1-7.
Dawson, John William [J. W.] Notes on Prototaxites and Pachytheca discovered by Dr. Hicks in the Denbighshire Grits of Corwen, North Wales, Reports and Proceedings, Royal Geological Society in Geological Magazine, 1882:40-41 and [with discussion] in the Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, May 1882:103-109.
Dawson, John William [J. W.] The Geological History of Plants. London: Kegan Trench and Co., 1888.
Dawson, John William [J. W.] On Nematophyton and allied forms from the Devonian (Erian) of Gaspe and Baie des Chaleurs; introductory notes, Proceedings and Transactions of the Royal Society of Canada, Sect.4, 1889:27-36.
Dawson, Rankine, ed. Fifty Years of Work in Canada: Scientific and Educational, Being Autobiographical Notes by Sir William Dawson (London and Edinburgh: Ballantyne, Hanson & Co., 1901).
Eagan, William B. The Debate Over the Canadian Shield, 1880-1905. Isis 80, 1989:232-253.
Eakins Peter R. and Jean Sinnamon Eakins. Sir John William Dawson. Dictionary of Canadian Biography. 12, 1990:230-237.
Ewan, Joseph, ed. A Short History of Botany in the United States (New York and London: Hafner Pub. Co., 1969).
Gaston, Jerry. The Reward System in British and American Science (Toronto: John Wiley and Sons, 1978).
Gensel, P. G. Renalia hueberi, a new plant from the Lower Devonian of Gaspe. Review Palaeobotany 22, 1976:19-37.
Gensel, P. G. On the Contributions of Sir J.W. Dawson to the Study of Early Land Plants (Devonian) and Current Ideas concerning their Nature, Diversity and Evolutionary Relationships, Proceedings, Third North American Paleontological Convention 1, August 1982:199-204.
Gensel, P. G. Diversification of land plants in the Early and Middle Devonian, in Land Plants: Notes for a Short Course, ed. T.W. Broadhead (Dept of Geological Science, Studies in Geology, No.15, Knoxville: University of Tennessee, 1986), 64-80.
Gensel, P. G. A new Lower Devonian Land plant and the early evolution of leaves. Nature 309, 1984:785-787.
Gensel, Patricia G. and Henry N. Andrews. Plant Life in the Devonian. New York: Praeger, 1984.
Graham, Linda E. Origin of Land Plants (New York and Toronto: John Wiley and Sons., Inc., 1993).
Hagstrom, W. O. The Scientific Community (New York: Basic Books, 1965).
Holland, Clifford. First Canadian Critics of Darwin. Queen's Quarterly 88, 1981:100-106.
Hotton, C. L., F. M. Hueber, D. H. Griffing, and J. S. Bridge. Early Terrestrial Plant Environments: An Example for the Emsian of Gaspe, Canada, in Plants Invade the Land: Evolutionary and Environmental Perspectives, eds Patricia Gensel and Dianne Edwards (New York: Columbia University Press, 2001), 179-203.
Hueber, T. M. Rotted Wood-Alga-Fungus: History and Life of Prototaxites. International Botanical Congress, 1999, Abstract No. 2844, Session 21.1.6 Available: http://www.biologie.uni-hamburg.de/bonline/ibc99/ibc/abstracts/listen/abstracts/2
Hueber, T. M. Rotted Wood-Alga-Fungus: A Solution to the Enigma of Prototaxites. The Palaeontological Society Special Publication, Sixth North American Palaeontological Conference Abstracts, 1996:183.
International Code of Botanical Nomenclature (Saint Louis Code) adopted by the Sixteenth International Botanical Congress, July-August 1999. Walter Greuter, gen. ed. (Konigstein, Germany: Koeltz Scientific Books, 2000).
Lang, W. H. On the plant remains from the Downtonian of England and Wales. Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society of London B227, 1937:245-291.
Lang, W. H. Pachytheca and some anomalous early plants (Prototaxites, Nematothallus, Parka, Foerstia, Orvillea n.g.). Journal of the Linnean Society, Botany 52, 1945:532-552.
Levere, Trevor H. and Richard A. Jarrell, eds. A Curious Field-book: Science and Society in Canadian History (Toronto: University of Toronto Press, 1974).
Merton, Robert K. The Ethos of Science, 1942, 267-276 and The Reward System of Science, 1957, 286-304 reprinted in Robert K. Merton: On Social Structure and Science ed. Piotr Sztompka (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1996).
McKillop, A. B. A Disciplined Intelligence: Critical Inquiry and Canadian Thought in the Victorian Era (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1979).
Morris, John, Review of On the Fossil Cycadean Stems from the Secondary Rocks of Britain. Transactions of the Linnean Society of London 26, 1870:675-708 and Geological Magazine 7, 1870:573-577.
Nicholson, H. Alleyne. The Ancient Life History of the Earth: A Comprehensive Outline of the Principles and Leading Facts of Palaeontological Science (New York: D. Appleton and Co., 1899).
Nicolson, Dan H. A History of Botanical Nomenclature. Annals of the Missouri Botanical Garden 78, 1991:33-56.
O'Brien, Charles F. Eozoön Canadense ‘The Dawn Animal of Canada.’ Isis 61, 1970:206-223.
O'Brien, Charles F. Sir William Dawson: A Life in Science and Religion. Memoirs of the American Philosophical Society, v. 84 (Philadelphia: American Philosophical Society, 1971).
Penhallow, David Pearce, On Nematophyton and Allied Forms from the Devonian (Erian) of Gaspe and Baie des Chaleurs, Proceedings and Transactions of the Royal Society of Canada, Sect.4, 1889, 6:27-47.
Rendle, A. B. William Carruthers, 1830-1922. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B 97, 1925:vi-viii.
Rudwick, Martin J. S. The Meaning of Fossils: Episodes in the History of Palaeontology. 2nd edition (Chicago and London: University of Chicago Press, 1985).
Seward, A. C. Fossil Plants: For Students of Botany and Geology, Vols1-4, 1898. (Reprint: New York and London: Hafner Pub. Co., 1969).
Seward, A. C. Plant Life Through the Ages: A Geological and Botanical Retrospect, 1931. (Reprint New York: Hafner Pub.Co., 1959).
Sheets-Pyenson, Susan. Sir William Dawson: the Nova Scotia Roots of a Geologist's Worldview, in Profiles of Science and Society in the Maritimes Prior to 1914, ed. Paul A. Bogaard (Fredericton: Acadiensis Press, 1990), 83-100.
Sheets-Pyenson, Susan. Sir William Dawson: John William Dawson: Faith, Hope, and Science (Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1996).
Sikes, Derek, University of Connecticut Paleobotany Collections: [Online] Available: www.eeb.uconn.edu/collections/fossilplants/fossilplants.html
Silliman, Robert H. The Hamlet Affair, Charles Lyell and the North Americans. Isis 86, 1995:541-561.
Smith, William G. William Carruthers, 1830-1922. Transactions and Proceedings of the Botanical Society of Edinburgh 28, 1921-22:118-121.
Thomas, Barry A. and Robert A. Spicer. The Evolution and Palaeobiology of Land Plants (London and Sydney: Croom Helm, 1987).
Woodward, Henry. Eminent Living Geologists: William Carruthers. Geological Magazine, 1912: 193-199.
On a Section at Junction-Road, Leith, Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 1862:450-453.
On an Undescribed Cone from the Carboniferous Beds of Airdrie, Lanarkshire, Geological Magazine, 1865, 2 :433-440.
On Araucarian Cones from the Secondary Bed of Britain, Geological Magazine, 1866, 3:249-252.
On Some Fossil Coniferous Fruits, Geological Magazine, 1866, 3:534-545.
On gymnospermatous fruits from the secondary rocks of Britain, Journal of Botany, British and Foreign, 1867, 5:1-21.
On British fossil Cycadeae, Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, 1867:80.
On Cycadoidea Yatesii, A Fossil Cycadean Stem from the Potton Sands, Bedfordshire, Geological Magazine, 1867, 4:199-201.
On Some Cycadean Fruits from the Secondary Rocks of Britain, Geological Magazine, 1867, 4:101-105.
On the Aroideous Fruit from the Stonesfield Slate, Geological Magazine, 1867, 4:146-147.
A Revision of the British Graptolites, with Descriptions of the New Series, and Notes on their Affinities, Geological Magazine, 1868, 5:64-74; and part 2, Geological Magazine, 1868, 5:125-132.
British Fossil Pandaneae, Geological Magazine, 1868, 5:153-156.
On Some Undescribed Coniferous Fruits from the Secondary Rocks of Britain, Geological Magazine, 1869, 6:1-7.
On Beania, a new genus of Cycadean fruit, from the Yorkshire Oolites, Geological Magazine, 1869, 6:97-99.
On the Plant Remains from the Brazilian Coal Beds, with remarks on the genus Flemingites, Geological Magazine, 1869, 6:151-155.
On the Structure and Affinities of Sigillaria and allied genera, Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 1869, 25:248-254.
The Cryptogamic Forests of the Coal Period, Geological Magazine, 1869, 6:289-300.
On the Genus Knorria, Journal of Botany, 1869, 7:153-155.
On the Structure of the Stems of the Aborescent [sic] Lycopodiaceae of the Coal Measures, no.1 Lepidodendron selaginoides, Sternb. Monthly Microscopic Journal: Transactions of the Royal Microscopical Society and Record of Histological Research, 1869, 1:177-181.
On the Structure of the Stems of the Aborescent [sic] Lycopodiaceae of the Coal Measures, no. 2 Ulodendron minus, Lindl. and Hutt., Monthly Microscopic Journal 1869, 1:225-227.
On the Petrified Forest Near Cairo, Geological Magazine, 1870, 7:306-310.
On the fossil Cycadean stems from the secondary rocks of Britain, Transactions of the Linnean Society of London, 1870, 26:675-708.
On the structure of a Fern-stem from the Lower Eocene of Herne Bay, and on its Allies, Recent and Fossil, Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 1870, 26:349-353.
On some supposed vegetable fossils, Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 1871, 27:443-448.
On Two Undescribed Coniferous Fruits from the Secondary Rocks of Britain, Geological Magazine 1871, 8:540-544.
On the Tree-Ferns of the Coal Measures, and their Affinities with Existing Forms, Journal of Botany, 1872, 10:279-281.
Notes on Some Fossil Plants, Geological Magazine, 1872, 9:49-59.
Notes on Fossil Plants from Queensland, Australia, Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, 1872, 28:350-356.
On the history, histological structure, and affinities of Nematophycus Logani, Carr. (Prototaxites Logani, Dawson), an alga of Devonian age, Monthly Microscopic Journal: Transactions of the Royal Microscopical Society and Record of Histological Research, 1872, 8:160-172.
On the Structure of the Stems of the Arborescent Lycopodiaceae of the Coal Measures. IV. On a Leaf-bearing branch of a species of Lepidodendron, Monthly Microscopic Journal, 1872, 7:50-54.
On Traquairia, a radiolarian rhizopod from the Coal Measures, Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, 1873, 42:126.
On Halonia of Lindley and Hutton and Cyclocladia of Goldenberg, Geological Magazine, 1873, 10:145-152.
Contribution to the Palaeobotany of Sweden, Geological Magazine New Series 2, 1882, 9:22-24.
On the Foliage of Sigillaria Serlii, Brongn. Geological Magazine New Series 2, 1883, 10:49-50.
Notes on Fossil Roots in the Sarsen Stones of Wiltshire, Geological Magazine New Series 3, 1885, 2:361-362.