Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 05 Nov 2007
Correspondence as a Window on the Development of a Discipline: Brongniart, Cleaveland, Silliman and the Maturation of Mineralogy in the First Decades of the Nineteenth Century
Correspondence as a Window on the Development of a Discipline: Brongniart, Cleaveland, Silliman and the Maturation of Mineralogy in the First Decades of the Nineteenth Century
Page Range: 198 – 245
The development of any scientific discipline owes much to communication and networking among peers. Mineralogy's maturation in the early nineteenth century profited not only from the publication of two key textbooks, one French and one American, but also from the subsequent correspondence of the two authors and their coteries. Alexandre Brongniart (1770-1847) produced his Traité élémentaire de minéralogie in 1807. Parker Cleaveland (1780-1858), of Bowdoin College, Maine, adopted the chemistry-based classification system of Brongniart, presenting An Elementary Treatise on Mineralogy and Geology in 1816 for an American audience. The two authors became correspondents, not only sharing ideas but also exchanging specimens. Cleaveland's friend, Benjamin Silliman, Sr. (1779-1864), of Yale College, entered the circle, corresponding with Brongniart, Cleaveland, and his own extended web of contacts. By considering the lives, contributions, and correspondence of the three men and their like-minded friends, we come to a deeper understanding of the evolution of geological disciplines and of issues of interest to naturalists in the first decades of the nineteenth century.
Aldrich, Michele L., Charles Thomas Jackson's geological surveys in New England, 1836-1844, Northeastern Geology, 1981, 3:5-10. Special thematic issue: History of Geology in the Northeast, ed. William M. Jordan.
Alger, Francis, An elementary treatise on mineralogy, 5th ed. (Boston: W. D. Ticknor and Company, 1844).
Bork, Kennard B., Parker Cleaveland, in American National Biography, ed. John A. Garraty and Mark C. Carnes, 24 vols. (New York: Oxford University Press, 1999), 5:42-44.
Bork, Kennard B., La relation entre Brongniart et Cleaveland, mise en évidence par un examplaire dédicacé du Mémoire sur les terrains de sédiment supérieurs calcaréo-trappéens du Vicentin de Brongniart (1823), in De la géologie à son histoire: ouvrage en hommage à François Ellenberger, ed. Gabriel Gohau (Paris: Comité des travaux historiques et scientifiques, 1997), 129-137.
Bork, Kennard B., Alexandre Brongniart, in Macmillan Encylopedia of Earth Sciences, ed. E. Julius Dasch (New York: Macmillan References USA, 1996), 1:59-61.
Bork, Kennard B., Elie Bertrand (1713-1797) sees God's Order in Nature's Record: the 1766 Recuil de divers traités sur l'histoire naturelle, Earth Sciences History, 1991, 10:73-88.
Brongniart, Alexandre, Traité élémentaire de minéralogie, avec des applications aux arts; ouvrage destiné à l'enseignement dans les lycées nationaux, 2 vols. (Paris: Chez Deterville, Libraire, 1807).
Brongniart, Alexandre, Sur le gisement; ou, Position relative des ophiolites, euphotides, jaspes, etc., dans quelques parties des Apennins (Paris: Imprimerie de Madame Huzard, 1821), 64 p.
Brongniart, Alexandre, Mémoire sur les terrains de sédiment supérieurs calcaréo-trappéens du Vicentin, et sur quelques terrains d'Italie, de France, d'Allemagne, etc., qui peuvent se rapporter à la même epoque (Paris: Chez F. G. Levrault, Libraire, 1823), 86 p.
Brongniart, Alexandre, Notes sur les coquilles fossiles qui se trouvent dans les terrains décrits par M. Studer; sur les époques géognostiques qu'elles indiquient, et sur la montagne de Diablerets, au N.-O. de Bex, Annales des Sciences Naturelles, Jour. Complém. des Annales de Chimie, 1827, Audin, Ad. Brongniart et Dumas, eds.
Brongniart, Alexandre, Traité des arts céramiques, ou des poteries considerées dans leur histoire, leur pratique et leur théorie (Paris: Bechet Jeune, 1844).
Brown, Chandos M., Benjamin Silliman: A Life in the Young Republic (Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, 1989), 377 p.
Burbank, Benjamin B., James Bowdoin and Parker Cleaveland, The Mineralogical Record, 1988, 19:145-152.
Burke, John G., Parker Cleaveland, in Dictionary of Scientific Biography, ed. Charles C. Gillispie, 18 vols. (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1971), 3:313.
Cleaveland, Nehemiah, Address Made at the Opening of the Cleaveland Cabinet of Bowdoin College (July 10, 1873) (Boston: James R. Osgood and Company, 1873).
Cleaveland, Nehemiah, and Alpheus S. Packard, History of Bowdoin College, with Biographical Sketches of its Graduates from 1806 to 1870, Inclusive (Boston: James Ripley Osgood and Company, 1882), 905 p.
Cleaveland, Parker, An Elementary Treatise on Mineralogy and Geology, Being an Introduction to the Study of these Sciences, and Designed for the Use of Pupils,—for Persons, Attending Lectures on these Subjects,—and as a Companion for Travellers in the United States of America (Boston: Cummings and Hilliard, 1816), 668 p.
Cleaveland, Parker, An Elementary Treatise on Mineralogy and Geology, Being an Introduction to the Study of these Sciences, and Designed for the Use of Pupils,—for Persons, Attending Lectures on these Subjects,—and as a Companion for Travellers in the United States of America, 2d ed. (Boston: Cummings and Hilliard, 1822), 818 p.
[Cooper, Thomas], Review of An Elementary Treatise on Mineralogy and Geology by Parker Cleaveland, Analectic Magazine, 1817, 9:301-314.
Cuvier, Georges, and Alexandre Brongniart, Essai sur la géographie minéralogique des environs de Paris, Journal des Mines, 1808, 23:421-458.
Cuvier, Georges and Alexandre Brongniart, Déscription géologique des environs de Paris, Nouv. édition, dans laquelle on a inseré la déscription d'un grand nombre de lieux de l'Allemagne, de la Suisse, de l'Italie, etc., qui presentent des terrains analogues à ceux du bassin de Paris, par M. Alex. Brongniart (Paris: G. Dufour et E. d'Ocagne, 1822), 428 p.
De la Beche, Henry T., A Selection of Geological Memoirs contained in the Annales des Mines, written by Brongniart, Humboldt, von Buch, and others. Translated, with notes and additions, by H. T. de la Beche (London: William Phillips, 1826), 335 p.
Druene, Bernard, L'aventure pyrénéenne d'Alexandre Brongniart (1793-94) (Extrait de la revue Pyrénées (Pau: Imprimerie Marrimpouey Jeune, 1987), 76 p.
Ellenberger, François, Histoire de la géologie, Tome 2, La grand éclosion et ses prémices, 1660-1810, 2 vols. (Paris: Technique et Documentation—Lavoisier, 1994), 381 p.
Elliott, Clark A., The American scientist in Antebellum society: a quantitative view, Social Studies of Science, 1975, 5:93-108.
Elliott, Clark A., Biographical Dictionary of American Science: The Seventeenth Through the Nineteenth Centuries (Westport, CT: Greenwood Press, 1979).
Ewell, John Louis, The story of Byfield, A New England Parish (Boston: George E. Littlefield, 1904), 344 p.
Eyles, Joan M., William Smith, Sir Joseph Banks and the French geologists, in From Linnaeus to Darwin: Commentaries on the History of Biology and Geology, ed. Alwyne Wheeler and J. H. Price, Society for the History of Natural History, Special Publication, 1985, 3:37-50.
Fulton, John R. and Elizabeth H. Thomson, Benjamin Silliman (1779-1864): Pathfinder in American Science (New York: Henry Schuman, 1947), 294 p.
Gohau, Gabriel, ed., De la géologie à son histoire (Paris: Comité des travaux historiques et scientifiques, 1997), 222 p.
Gohau, Gabriel, Histoire de la géologie (Paris: Editions la Découverte, 1987), 259 p.
Gohau, Gabriel, A History of Geology, revised and translated by A. V. Carozzi (New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press, 1990), 259 p.
Greene, John C., Protestantism, science, and American enterprise: Benjamin Silliman's Moral Universe, in Benjamin Silliman and his Circle, ed. Leonard G. Wilson (New York: Science History Publications, 1979), 11-27.
Greene, John C., and John G. Burke, The Science of Minerals in the Age of Jefferson, Transactions of the American Philosophical Society, 68(4) (Philadelphia, 1978), 113 p.
Greene, Mott T., History of Geology, OSIRIS, 2d ser., 1985, 1:97-116.
Guralnick, Stanley M., Sources of Misconception on the Role of Science in the Nineteenth-century American College, ISIS, 1974, 65:352-366.
Guralnick, Stanley M., Science and the Ante-Bellum American College, American Philosophical Society Memoir no. 109 (Philadelphia, 1975), 227 p.
Hatch, Louis C., The History of Bowdoin College (Portland, Me: Loring, Short, and Harmon, 1927), 500 p.
Hazen, Robert M., ed., North American Geology: Early Writings, Benchmark Papers in Geology, No. 51 (Stroudsburg, PA: Dowden, Hutchinson, and Ross, 1979), 356 p.
Hussey, Arthur M. II, James Bowdoin III and geology at Bowdoin College, in The Legacy of James Bowdoin III (Brunswick, ME: Bowdoin College Museum of Art, 1994), 127-138.
Jordan, William M., ed., History of Geology in the Northeast, Northeastern Geology, 1981, 3(1), 103 p. Special thematic issue.
Kohlstedt, Sally Gregory, Curiosities and cabinets: natural history museums and education on the antebellum campus, ISIS, 1988, 79:405-426.
Kohlstedt, Sally Gregory, Parlors, primers, and public schooling: education for science in nineteenth-century America, ISIS, 1990, 81:425-445.
Laudan, Rachel, From Mineralogy to Geology: The Foundations of a Science, 1650-1830 (Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1987), 278 p.
Launay, Louis de, Les Brongniart: une grande famille de savants (Paris: Librairie G. Rapilly et fils, 1940), 208 p.
Merrill, George P., The First One Hundred Years of American Geology (New York: Hafner Publishing, 1924, 1964 facsimile edition), 773 p.
Newcomb, Sally, The ideas of A. G. Werner and J. Hutton in America, Earth Sciences History, 1990, 9(2):96-107.
Newell, Julie R., American Geologists and Their Geology: The Formation of the American Geological Community, 1780-1865, Ph.D. Diss., University of Wisconsin-Madison, 1993, 371 p.
Outram, Dorinda, The Letters of Georges Cuvier: A summary calendar of manuscript and printed materials preserved in Europe, the United States of America, and Australasia, British Society for the History of Science Monograph 2 (Chalfont St. Giles, England, 1979), 102 p.
Préaud, Tamara, Sèvres Porcelain (Washington, D.C.: Smithsonian Institution Press, 1990), 95 p.
Préaud, Tamara, The Sèvres Porcelain Manufactory: Alexandre Brongniart and the Triumph of Art and Industry, 1800-1847 (New Haven: Yale University Press, 1997), 416 p.
Rudwick, Martin J. S., Alexandre Brongniart, in Dictionary of Scientific Biography, ed. Charles C. Gillispie, 18 vols. (New York: Charles Scribner's Sons, 1970), 2:493-497.
Rudwick, Martin J. S., Cuvier and Brongniart, William Smith, and the reconstruction of geohistory, Earth Sciences History, 1996, 15(1):25-36.
Rudwick, Martin J. S., Smith, Cuvier et Brongniart, et la reconstitution de la géohistoire, in De la géologie à son histoire, ed. Gabriel Gohau, (Paris: Comité des travaux historiques et scientifiques, 1997), 119-128.
Silliman, Benjamin, Sr., A Journal of Travels in England, Holland and Scotland, and of two passages over the Atlantic in the years 1805 and 1806 (New Haven: T. B. Wait and Co., for Howe and Deforest, and Increase Cook, 1812).
Silliman, Benjamin Sr., Review of An Elementary Treatise on Mineralogy and Geology … by Parker Cleaveland, American Journal of Science, 1819, 1:35-52.
Silliman, Benjamin Sr., Elements of Chemistry in the Order of the Lectures Given in Yale College (New Haven: H. Howe, 1830-1831).
Silliman, Benjamin Sr., Suggestions relative to the Philosophy of Geology, as deduced from the facts and to the consistency of both the facts and theory of this Science with Sacred History, in Introduction to Geology, ed. Robert Bakewell, 3d American edition (from 5th London edition) (New Haven: B. and W. Noyes, 1839).
Silliman, Benjamin Sr., Obituary—Death of Professor Parker Cleaveland, of Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Maine, American Journal of Science and Arts, 2d ser., 1858, 26:448-449.
Taylor, Kenneth L., American geological investigations and the French, 1750-1850, Earth Sciences History, 1990, 9(2):118-125.
Torrens, Hugh S., Geology in peace time: an English visit to study German mineralogy and geology (and visit Goethe, Werner and Raumer) in 1816, in Toward a History of Mineralogy, Petrology, and Geochemistry, ed. Bernhard Fritscher and Fergus Henderson, Proceedings of International Symposium on the History of Mineralogy, Petrology, and Geochemistry, Munich, March 8-9, 1996 (München: Institut für Geschichte der Naturwissenschaften, 1998), Algorismus, 23:147-175.
Wilson, Leonard G., Benjamin Silliman and his Circle: Studies on The Influence of Benjamin Silliman on Science in America—Prepared in Honor of Elizabeth H. Thomson (New York: Science History Publications, 1979), 227 p.