Editorial Type:
Article Category: Research Article
| Online Publication Date: 05 Nov 2007
Defining the Base of the Cambrian: The Hicks-Geikie Confrontation of April 1883
Defining the Base of the Cambrian: The Hicks-Geikie Confrontation of April 1883
and
Page Range: 70 – 80
The British geological community in the 1880's was deeply divided between the ‘professionals’ of the Geological Survey and the so-called ‘amateurs’ in the more traditional mode. Perhaps no one paper produced as much hostility between these two camps as Geikie's, ‘On the supposed Precambrian rocks of St. David's’ which was read before the Geological Society of London in the spring of 1883. An intense debate was provoked, the minutes of which were published shortly afterwards in the Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society. Presented here is an unofficial eye-witness account of that meeting, which was taken down in short-hand during the debate itself. It reveals the true vehemence with which the participants exchanged their views, and is fascinating to compare with the published account.
Bailey, E. B., 1926, Obituary: Benjamin Neeve Peach: Geological Magazine, v. 63, p. 187-190.
Blake, J. F., 1884, On the volcanic group at St. David's: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 40, p. 294-310.
Burchfield, J. D., 1990, Lord Kelvin and the age of the Earth. Chicago, University of Chicago Press.
Callaway, C., 1879, The Pre-cambrian rocks of Shropshire Pt. 1. With notes on the microscopic structure of some of the rocks, by T.G. Bonney: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 35, p. 643-669.
Callaway, C., 1880, On a second Precambrian group in the Malvern hills: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 36, p. 536-539.
Callaway, C., 1885, A plea for comparative lithology: Geological Magazine, decade 3(2), p. 258-264.
Challinor, J., 1979, History of the study of the ‘Pre-Cambrian’ in Wales: Pp. 32-49. In W. O. Kupsch and W. A. S. Sarjeant (eds.) History of Concepts in Precambrian Geology. Geological Association of Canada, Special paper 19.
Davies, J. R. A., 1884, Oldest Wales: a popular sketch of some of Dr. Hicks's work among early Welsh rocks: University College of Wales Magazine v. 6, p. 230-234.
Geikie, A., 1868, On the order of succession among the Silurian rocks of Scotland: Transactions of the Geological Society of Glasgow, v. 3, p. 74-95.
Geikie, A., 1883, On the supposed Pre-Cambrian rocks at St. David's: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 39, p. 261-326.
Geikie, A., 1884, The origin of crystalline schists: Nature, v. 30, p. 121-123.
Green, J. F. N., 1908, The geological structure of the St. David's area (Pembrokeshire): Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 64, p. 363-383.
Hamilton, B., 1988, British geologists' changing perceptions of Precambrian time in the nineteenth century: Earth Sciences History, v. 18, p. 141-149.
Harker, A., 1906, Geological structure of the Sgúrr of Eigg: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 62, p. 40-67.
Hicks, H., 1874, On the classification of the Cambrian and Silurian rocks: Proceedings of the Geologists' Association, v. 3, p. 99-105.
Hicks, H., 1875a, On the succession of the ancient rocks in the vicinity of St. Davids, Pembrokeshire, with special reference to those of the Arenig and Llandeilo groups, and their fossil contents: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 31, p. 167-195.
Hicks, H., 1875b, The physical condition under which the Cambrian rocks were probably deposited over the Europe area: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 31, p. 552-558.
Hicks, H., 1877, On the Pre-Cambrian (Dimetian and Pebidian) rocks of St. Davids: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 34, p. 147-152.
Hicks, H., 1878, On some Pre-Cambrian (Dimetian and Pebidian) rocks in Caernarvonshire: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 34, p. 147-152.
Hicks, H., 1879, On some new areas of Pre-Cambrian rocks in N. Wales: British Association Report 1878, p. 536-537.
Hicks, H., 1883, On some recent researches among Pre-Cambrian rocks in the British Isles: Proceedings of the Geologists' Association, v. 7, p. 59-87 and 281-297.
Holl, H. B., 1865, On the geological structure of the Malvera Hills and adjacent districts: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 21, p. 72-102.
Hughes, T. McKenney, 1884, On the brecciated beds in the Dime-tian at St. David's: Geological Magazine, v. 2, p. 306-309.
Hunt, T. Sterry, 1872, History of the names Cambrian and Silurian in geology: Nature, v. 6, p. 15-17, 34-37, 53-55.
Lapworth, C., 1879, On the tripartite classification of the Lower Palaeozoic rocks: Geological Magazine, decade 2(6), p. 1-15.
Lyell, C., 1865, Elements of Geology: or the ancient change of the earth and its inhabitants as illustrated by geological monuments, fifth edition. London, John Murray.
Murchison, R. I., 1859, Siluria. The History of the. Older Fossiliferous Rocks and their Foundations; with a Brief Sketch of the Distribution of Gold on the Earth, third edition. London. John Murray.
Oldroyd, D. R., 1990. The Highlands Controversy: constructing Geological Knowledge through fieldwork in Nineteenth Century Britain. Chicago University Press, Chicago.
Oldroyd, D. R., In press: The Archaean Controversy in Britain: Part 1-The rocks of St. David's. Annals of Science.
Plant, J., 1865, Are the slate rocks of Charnwood Forest Laurentian?: Geological Magazine, v. 2, p. 233.
Porter, R., 1978, Gentlemen and geology: the emergence of a scientific career, 1600-1920: The Historical Journal, v. 21, p. 809-836.
Rudler, R. W., 1887, Fifty years' progress in British geology: Proceedings of the Geologists' Association, v. 10, p. 234-272.
Rudwick, M. J. S., 1985, The great Devonian controversey: the shaping of scientific knowledge among gentlemanly specialists. Chicago University Press, Chicago.
Salter, J. W., 1863, On the discovery of Paradoxides in Britain: Quarterly Journal of the Geological Society, v. 19, p. 274-277.
Salter, J. W., 1865, On some new forms of olenoid trilobites from the lowest fossiliferous rocks of Wales: British Association Report, 1864, p. 87.
Secord, J. A., 1985, John W. Salter: the rise and fall of a Victorian palaeontological career: In A. Wheeler and J. H. Price. From Linnaeus to Darwin: commentaries on the history of geology and biology. London 1985.
Secord, J. A., 1986, Controversy in Victorian geology: The Cambrian-Silurian dispute: Princeton University Press, Princeton. 363 pp.